Inside the re-making of Fernando Mendoza from shaky starter to 2026 NFL first-rounder

MisterGopher

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 12, 2008
Messages
482
Reaction score
288
Points
63
https://www.nytimes.com/athletic/70...o-mendoza-2026-nfl-draft-indiana-development/

How did Fernando Mendoza go from being rated a two-star recruit once ranked the 140th-best quarterback in the Class of 2022 to a Heisman Trophy winner — and the projected first pick of the 2026 NFL Draft?

And how did he do it so quickly?

In two seasons at Cal, as the starter in 2024 and in significant action in 2023, Mendoza threw 30 touchdowns and 16 interceptions to go 10-10 overall. He ranked No. 36 in passer rating in 2024.

But Hoosiers head coach Curt Cignetti was intrigued. He had signed Mendoza’s younger brother, Alberto, at James Madison before taking the job in Bloomington in 2024.

“Special family,” Cignetti said. “They were all high achievers.”

Cignetti, a self-described “tape junkie,” liked what he saw from Mendoza on film: his arm, his mobility, his stature. The 64-year-old believed that Mendoza would follow a similar arc as his other standout QBs: “Not great the first half of spring, a lot better in the second half of spring, they have a good summer. Fall camp, different player. Better at the end of fall camp, and then they build on their success early in the season, and they just get better and better and better, because with success comes belief, and with belief comes confidence.”

:

“However, Coach Cignetti really sold me on, we’re going to develop you,” Mendoza said. The quarterback recalled Cignetti’s pitch: “‘I don’t have a crystal ball. I can’t tell if we’re going to be top 25 in the nation, No. 1, or outside of that top 25. However, I know that I develop quarterbacks. It’s what I do.’

“With the help of Coach Whitmer, who’s been phenomenal, Coach (Mike) Shanahan and Coach Cignetti, I’ve been able to develop into that quarterback, and made that exponential jump this year that I was aspiring to,” Mendoza said. “I really am thankful that he sold me on developing Fernando as the quarterback. That’s one of the things that made me decide on this school. I want to be the best quarterback that I can control. It goes back to the concepts of controlling the controllables and staying in the present moment.”

:

Mendoza’s feel-good journey​

Even though he grew up in a talent hotbed in South Florida, Mendoza was an afterthought to most college programs. He had some FCS offers after his junior season at Miami’s Columbus High. He committed to Yale before his senior year, then eventually signed with Cal.

Mendoza lived three miles from Florida International University and begged the Panthers to take him, said Akron offensive line coach Joel Rodriguez, FIU’s O-line coach at the time.

“Our QB coach, who is no longer a coach in college football, kept saying ‘no.’ (Mendoza) wasn’t big enough, strong enough, fast enough or whatever. He was like what he is now, except 20 pounds lighter and goofier. But he had beaten Miami Northwestern (High) and (Miami) Central, and that holds weight,” Rodriguez said. “I have legitimate memories from talking to Jason Hill, the recruiting guy at Columbus, and Dave Dunn, the head coach, and they were like, ‘What the hell are you guys thinking?’ I said, ‘I wish I could tell you.’ It wouldn’t have mattered anyway.”

“At that point in my journey, I’m not going to lie and say I was a five-star prospect,” Mendoza said two days before the national title game, played in the city he grew up in, against Miami, the team he grew up rooting for. “I was a two-star prospect. I sucked; like, I was not very good.

“It’s a part of the journey, and a lot of kids get wrapped up in the identity: ‘Oh, that’s who I am.’ At that point, you can still improve. I was a two-star then, and now I hope I’ve been better than a two-star playing there. It’s only a little mark, a little identification, just because college recruiting is so tough nowadays.

“However, it’s your decision at that point on how you’re going to have that work ethic and how you’re going to develop as a player to get better and better every single day. A lot of our players (at Indiana) that are three- and four-stars that have all those great stats have really put in the work ethic and changed their mindset and not let themselves fall into the trap that that’s their identity.”

Whitmer, recalling his three seasons on the Chargers’ staff, likened Mendoza’s mentality to that of Los Angeles quarterback Justin Herbert.

“They’re very similar because they’re both perfectionists,” he said. “Both Type A. Super-high academic guys. Very intellectual. They want to know every detail. They’ll ask all the hard questions. They’re both tremendous human beings and obviously high-level talents.”

“The biggest area of development from 2024 to 2025 was Mendoza’s ability to play on time with better consistency,” said The Athletic’s NFL Draft analyst Dane Brugler. “He showed poise and clutch moments at Cal, but had the bad habit of rushing his process. That was mostly a product of poor protection and a subpar offensive system.

“Before Mendoza ever took a snap at Indiana, he was in the first round of my way-too-early mock draft last April. His accuracy, processing and ability to layer throws formed an outstanding foundation, and there was the hope that he would only get better with Cignetti.”

He did.
 

This is a good read, against the grain that IU just bought the sure thing, finished product. I didn’t know that Cignetti had signed Fernando’s brother to JMU before he even knew about the job at IU. That would be a very long game to play to get Fernando. Sure Fernando got plenty of money but I don’t think a lot of programs were after him as their guaranteed championship QB. The critics shifted from “yeah but they’re going to fold in big games like they did last year” to “well anyone can win a natty if they just buy a Heisman QB off the shelf.”
 

If Cignetti's staff turned Mendoza into a Heisman winner, then they would have done the same thing with Rourke in 2024.
 

If Cignetti's staff turned Mendoza into a Heisman winner, then they would have done the same thing with Rourke in 2024.
Or did they? He did set the school record for passing touchdowns at Indiana with 29. He did play his entire season for Cignetti on a torn ACL and had surgery after the regular season. Rourke did get drafted by the 49ers. The surrounding talent improved for Mendoza. So, I wouldn't exactly say Cignetti failed Rourke.
 

Or did they? He did set the school record for passing touchdowns at Indiana with 29. He did play his entire season for Cignetti on a torn ACL and had surgery after the regular season. Rourke did get drafted by the 49ers. The surrounding talent improved for Mendoza. So, I wouldn't exactly say Cignetti failed Rourke.
Nor did I. But they didn't turn him into a Heisman.

Mendoza would've won the Heisman at Miami and several other schools.
 




Nor did I. But they didn't turn him into a Heisman.

Mendoza would've won the Heisman at Miami and several other schools.
LOL I don't even know what the argument started as here...I just think Cignetti has been unparalleled in his coaching accomplishment. Not saying Mendoza is not good but those receivers up until Miami...I don't think they ever dropped a ball all season, their contested catches would make any QB look good. They also made circus catches....to me it's more Cignetti than Mendoza....but again, I'm not saying Mendoza is not good. I do disagree if Mendoza is at Miami or elsewhere he wins the Heisman. Without the Indiana rags to riches mystique I think Diego Pavia
woulda been the winner.
Time will tell how big a splash Mendoza makes in the NFL. Top 10 QB?
 

LOL I don't even know what the argument started as here...I just think Cignetti has been unparalleled in his coaching accomplishment. Not saying Mendoza is not good but those receivers up until Miami...I don't think they ever dropped a ball all season, their contested catches would make any QB look good. They also made circus catches....to me it's more Cignetti than Mendoza....but again, I'm not saying Mendoza is not good. I do disagree if Mendoza is at Miami or elsewhere he wins the Heisman. Without the Indiana rags to riches mystique I think Diego Pavia
woulda been the winner.
Time will tell how big a splash Mendoza makes in the NFL. Top 10 QB?
We can agree to disagree.

If Rourke had another year of eligibility and they kept him as the QB instead of going out to get the older Mendoza, they lose at least two regular season games last year and who knows about the playoffs.

QB is by far the one position in football where you take a massive hit to the overall performance of your team by one guy being degraded. No other position is like that.
 



Or did they? He did set the school record for passing touchdowns at Indiana with 29. He did play his entire season for Cignetti on a torn ACL and had surgery after the regular season. Rourke did get drafted by the 49ers. The surrounding talent improved for Mendoza. So, I wouldn't exactly say Cignetti failed Rourke.
I just want to see Gopher QBs improve and develop. I am sure that they do improve, but not like Cignetti has done. IMHO we have never had a QB whisperer.
 

What did Mendoza do at Cal that makes you so sure he would win the Heisman without Cignetti? Mendoza's last year at Cal stat line mirrored Drake Lindsey's this year but with a higher completion percentage. Mendoza is obviously good but so are a lot of QB's. To achieve the Heisman it comes down to two things. Either they are that much better than everyone else, which in my opinion isn't the case, or it is the right situation.
 




Top Bottom