I think the biggest issue is producing NFL talent. There are currently four active players in the NFL from The University of Minnesota. That's terrible, and less than the following non-BCS schools:
-Appalachian State
-Arkansas State
-Boise State
-BYU
-Central Florida
-Central Michigan
-Colorado State
-UCONN
-East Carolina
-Florida International
-Fresno State
-Hawaii
-Houston
-Kent State
-Louisiana Tech
-Louisiana-Lafayette
-Memphis
-Miami (OH)
-UMass
-Marshall
-Nevada
-UNLV
-New Mexico State
-Ohio
-Rice
-San Diego State
-USF
-SMU
-Southern Miss
-Temple
-UTEP
-Toledo
-Troy
-Utah State
-Western Michigan
-Wyoming
And the following FCS and Division II schools (including ties):
-Abeliene Christian
-Alabama State
-California (PA)
-Delaware
-Eastern Washington
-Grand Valley State
-Hampton
-Hofstra
-James Madison
-North Dakota State
-Portland State
-Richmond
-South Carolina State
-Southern Illinois
-West Texas A&M
-William & Mary
We're dead last in BCS programs.
While this isn't Kill's fault, it is a huge problem, and for those of you that say "I don't care about making NFL players, I care about making college players", this is hurting us to that end as well. The ultimate goal of the majority of HS kids with D1 offers is to make the NFL. When Illinois has produced 25 NFL players, Rutgers has produced 23, and FCS school Delaware has produced 7, we need to skyrocket our current number to make that appeal.