I am not a conspiracy theory guy but..,

…it sure does seem like there are some questionable calls in close games vs Ohio State and Michigan.

1. That time the Gophers were hanging with Ohio State and Leidner took a helmet crown right to his face on a pick 6 play. It was called right on the field but somehow was overturned on review, allowing the pick six to stand. B1G office admitted the head scratching mistake later, I believe.

2. That time (2018?) the Gophers were trading touchdowns with Ohio State and looked surprising good against the Buckeyes until a phantom ref ball spot gave OSU a first down that led to an unearned TD.

3. That time another targeting foul was overlooked against OSU in the season opener, but upon review the refs did decide the concussed Gopher receiver did somehow have possession long enough to fumble. OSU ball, game over.

4. And of course today with the phantom onside kick offsides call.

5. Don’t forget prior to the phantom offsides call, the refs also tried to take away Jackson’s TD catch, which was perfect in every way. Very obvious on replay thankfully.

Who knows if the Gophers would have won any of those games? But when you are playing teams with that many advantages, it takes a Herculean effort to not only overcome the opponent, but the refs too.

There can be a bad call in any game, but it does not take a huge imagination to wonder out loud about conference and reffing goals when this stuff seems to consistently benefit the conference’s golden geese.
Bottom line: if the Gophers are going to beat OSU or Michigan, they have to win clearly. Razor thin goes to the ranked team. We made too many mistakes early. Upside: we learned again that Brosmer and our receivers can play if you let them (and OL holds their blocks for 4 seconds).
 

The easiest explanation is usually the correct explanation. There was no bias it was simply a ref making a bad call. It sucks, and we got screwed. But please tell me the motivation that referee had when he threw the flag. I’m really supposed to believe he had something to gain? He couldn’t care less who wins the game he only wants to be accurate with every call he makes and he made a bad call.
Watch the documentary on Tim Donaghy. The NBA ref who bet on games. He does a solid job describing the "suggestions" refs were given by league officials. Certain teams winning is good for the league, whatever league. I'm not saying today was that, but you have to wonder.
 

Watch the documentary on Tim Donaghy. The NBA ref who bet on games. He does a solid job describing the "suggestions" refs were given by league officials. Certain teams winning is good for the league, whatever league. I'm not saying today was that, but you have to wonder.

Considering the ways money are made legally and illegally and incentives involved, opaque nature of the business well, no business or industry is immune to the potential phenomenon.

As ludicrous as I may sound I’m not saying Uncle Guido has infiltrated or is manning the Big Ten Officiating HQ or C Suite in Illinois but, that or othe less Hollywood and more nuanced financial derivations and influences and connections could exist….truth can be stranger than fiction and there are plenty of people “amenable” to influence.

Tinfoil hat in hand.
 

Gophers have been on the wrong end (and good side) of other calls against other opponents like Purdue, to be sure. But that isn’t my point. My point is the consistency it has happened vs OSU and to a lesser extent but notable ways against Mich and PSU too.
Agree. I have written this a couple of times. There is no conspiracy against the Gophers. But in close games vs. Ohio St or Michigan, when a critical, 50/50 call has to be made, we get the short end of the deal. Count on it. I remember a tight game was vs Michigan a few years ago, Beth Mowens (sp) was calling the game and she blurts out, "there is no way Minnesota is going to get a call." A Michigan DL guy unloaded on Cupito well after the ball was thrown and she said, "that hit looks to be a little late." No flag of course.
 



Agree. I have written this a couple of times. There is no conspiracy against the Gophers. But in close games vs. Ohio St or Michigan, when a critical, 50/50 call has to be made, we get the short end of the deal. Count on it. I remember a tight game was vs Michigan a few years ago, Beth Mowens (sp) was calling the game and she blurts out, "there is no way Minnesota is going to get a call." A Michigan DL guy unloaded on Cupito well after the ball was thrown and she said, "that hit looks to be a little late." No flag of course.
This is a 100% true. But I see it as a bigger thing. It's not just the Gophers. Purdue, Indiana, Illinois, etc have all been effed over more times than you can count vs the big boys. Happens every year. Was the ref deliberately trying to make the Gophers lose? Doubtful. But there is something in the Big Ref world that says "if it's a close call, especially in a close game, you call it in favor of the Buckeyes or Wolverines." And that is absolute.
 

Refs know the B1G wants Championship contenders, it raises the profile of the B1G and keeps the money flowing.
 

Agree. I have written this a couple of times. There is no conspiracy against the Gophers. But in close games vs. Ohio St or Michigan, when a critical, 50/50 call has to be made, we get the short end of the deal. Count on it. I remember a tight game was vs Michigan a few years ago, Beth Mowens (sp) was calling the game and she blurts out, "there is no way Minnesota is going to get a call." A Michigan DL guy unloaded on Cupito well after the ball was thrown and she said, "that hit looks to be a little late." No flag of course.
Beth Mowins was doing games when Cupito played?
 

Refs know the B1G wants Championship contenders, it raises the profile of the B1G and keeps the money flowing.
for this, blame the league more than the B1G. The corruption that is the SEC, the ACC, the old Big 12, and the old PaC are all rife with examples like this. Fairness is less important than money and power. Bank on it. Fans still show and networks still air the games, regardless of the outcomes being all but predetermined.
 





I once was a conspiracy theorist but then I realized the theories were true.. Ever fing one of them…
 








Let me put it this way. Every fanbase in the country could easily put together a long list of bad calls that cost them a game. Every fanbase in the country including the blue bloods. This isn’t unique to us. It’s human beings as referees and that’s all.

Exactly. In college football you have to expect bad calls on both sides. Until the conference gets professional officials it will continue.
 

The easiest explanation is usually the correct explanation. There was no bias it was simply a ref making a bad call. It sucks, and we got screwed. But please tell me the motivation that referee had when he threw the flag. I’m really supposed to believe he had something to gain? He couldn’t care less who wins the game he only wants to be accurate with every call he makes and he made a bad call.
Refs lose jobs if they blow calls regularly.
 

Exactly. In college football you have to expect bad calls on both sides. Until the conference gets professional officials it will continue.
What would make them more professional and what would they do the rest of the week?
 

This site may post a blurb or NCAA explanation later this week. I’m not expecting anything earth shattering except it was correct to the letter of the law and we have no evidence otherwise.




For the NFL fans here, the site also lists the crews, years of experience, college, and prior or concurrent real world occupations.
 




Watch the documentary on Tim Donaghy. The NBA ref who bet on games. He does a solid job describing the "suggestions" refs were given by league officials. Certain teams winning is good for the league, whatever league. I'm not saying today was that, but you have to wonder.
Michael Jordan resembled a running back as much as a basketball player once he reached Basketball Sainthood. What's a pivot foot?

PS--I do want to see an explanation one way or the other from the B1G offices this week. I think they review officials on a game-by-game basis and then make decisions at the end of the year as to whether they should be retained at the level they are reffing. It's a little different at the professional level because the officials are unionized, thus harder to get rid of them (see baseball umpire Angel Hernandez as Exhibit A).
 
Last edited:

What would make them more professional and what would they do the rest of the week?

Officiating being their main job would make them more professional.

I don't care what they do the rest of the week. Whatever officials do to train and get better at their jobs.
 

There’s way too much money in sports for there not to be some level of corruption.
 

OSU, Michigan, and Penn State have always been protected teams and have gotten some brutally bad calls go their way over the years. I'll never forget the phantom PI in OT on 4th down against PSU in 2006.
*sigh*

-schedules therapy session-
 

If he was offside, it was by an inch and we kicked the ball to the other side.

No, I think we kicked it to his side and he was one of the people around the recovery.

But, on the other hand, we kept a td drive going when we literally ripped the helmet off a pass rusher.
This. I was going to post just that. The penalty for hands to the face on #55 for Michigan got us the ball back with a first down that led to our TD, whereas Mich was set to take over on downs. The hands to the face by Ersery was clearly worse as it took the Michigan player's helmet off and wasn't called.

How many on here would be claiming a conspiracy theory if our guy had his helmet taken off with no penalty on Michigan?

Also on that same drive I believe, our right guard had his entire right arm wrapped around #78 for Michigan as he was beaten in pass protection, yet no flag.

Either one of those penalties could have stalled our TD drive.

So while I feel bad for #49 for the Gophers, as that had to be gut wrenching, the refs helped put us in that position.
 




Top Bottom