Let's face it, Fleck is a good recruiter and motivator, but not good at X's and O's and adjustments, decision making. As someone said on here, and as I've said before, he needs to rely on good coordinators. He doesn't have a "killer" instinct, and is too stubborn to change his way of thinking. I was excited after the Kill era, because if there was one thing I didn't like about Jerry Kill's coaching was that he was too conservative. Well, Fleck is exactly the same. The best coaches are not the ones that play for a tie. It's the ones that aren't afraid to take chance and go for the win, or the throat when winning.
Last night, while we were behind by 3 and just got within field goal distance, I knew Fleck was just going be conservative and play for the field goal. I wrote in the game thread that knowing Fleck, he was gonna just play it safe and just go for the field goal. Of course the other coaching staff can read him like a book too, so they stacked the box all night on first and second, and of course Fleck runs right into them. 4 yard loss.... 50+ field goal miss.
Yes, the program is in a better spot. Yes, I do like how Fleck has carries this program. But we have to come to the realization that this is as good as we'll ever be. 9 wins and a bowl game is our ceiling. Lindsey is great, and will play in the NFL and be a high pick... but even if we had Cal's QB, our outcome would still be the same... We'd lose, because of Fleck's conservative nature to an opponent that has similar talent and good coaching.
People seem to think that football is just based off of players executing or not. It's so much more than that. There is a real chess game between the coaching staffs. I don't know the stats, but I feel like Lindsey had to carry the coaching staff out of 3rd and long holes almost 10+ times. How good are the player's chances of "executing" if they're running against stacked boxes and we run right into them? Even the INT, yes it was a bad throw, not sure if it was a miscommunication or not, but even that was on 3rd and long. If it's 3rd and long, if I'm the defender, i'm waiting to break on one every single time! Especially with a redshirt freshman. So it almost felt like Fleck and his coaching staff don't even trust Lindsey, so they keep forcing the run against 8 or 9 in the box on first and second down. But time and time again Lindsey, although only in his 3rd college start ever, kept making perfect throws to dig us out.
TLDR:
Fleck is a coward, needs good coordinators, this is our ceiling (unless he changes, but I doubt it), it's not about executing, and Lindsey is good, real good.