Bayfieldgopher
Well-known member
- Joined
- Nov 20, 2008
- Messages
- 9,046
- Reaction score
- 1,549
- Points
- 113
Read where he is doing his second visit this weekend. Good sign
So, looking at the timeline on 247, is this one an official?Read where he is doing his second visit this weekend. Good sign
I wish...Samaki’s kid? Nice.
To be clear, I have no knowledge but there are plenty of reasons i.e. player has little or no interest in playing here or player doesn't seem to have the personality to impact team chemistry the way they need or the strengths or weakness of court play don't match as well as the team needs.I don't want to get in a comparison thing but I'm kind of confused why are we prioritizing this guy who is ranked 2 spots ahead of Jalen Wilson and whose games are eerily similar over Wilson who is from here. It's not like this kid is a game changer any more than Wilson and I thought the point of hiring Ben is to bring in kids from here who are at the top of their class
I think the top kids staying home consistently won't happen until the Gophers are relevant in the conference again. It's probably more likely Ben can land an out of state kid looking for new scenery, versus an in state kid who knows definitively how irrelevant the program is currently. He's had a reasonably good start getting in-state kids that probably would have gone elsewhere if the previous head coach were here. He needs to win big before we start getting the attention of in-state players with a serious offer sheet.I don't want to get in a comparison thing but I'm kind of confused why are we prioritizing this guy who is ranked 2 spots ahead of Jalen Wilson and whose games are eerily similar over Wilson who is from here. It's not like this kid is a game changer any more than Wilson and I thought the point of hiring Ben is to bring in kids from here who are at the top of their class
I understand this, but why not offer the in-state kid? I am not even talking about the landing part. Still, after hearing the McAndrews interview about not even receiving an offer and other top kids in the 2024 class not receiving an offer, I would at least think we offer 1 or 2 per year so when they commit elsewhere, they can't pull the bs and say we never showed any interest.I think the top kids staying home consistently won't happen until the Gophers are relevant in the conference again. It's probably more likely Ben can land an out of state kid looking for new scenery, versus an in state kid who knows definitively how irrelevant the program is currently. He's had a reasonably good start getting in-state kids that probably would have gone elsewhere if the previous head coach were here. He needs to win big before we start getting the attention of in-state players with a serious offer sheet.
Maybe he's just a bad fit. Maybe he has no interest in staying home. The possibilities are endless.I understand this, but why not offer the in-state kid? I am not even talking about the landing part. Still, after hearing the McAndrews interview about not even receiving an offer and other top kids in the 2024 class not receiving an offer, I would at least think we offer 1 or 2 per year so when they commit elsewhere, they can't pull the bs and say we never showed any interest.
Seems to me they prioritized Asuma over Freitag, Robison was never comming to the U, not sure about McAndrews, he would be a miss to me, maybe they just liked Grove more. Asuma and Grove commited pretty quickly though. Just because the recruiting sites rated other guys higher doesn't mean the Gophers staff rated them the same.I understand this, but why not offer the in-state kid? I am not even talking about the landing part. Still, after hearing the McAndrews interview about not even receiving an offer and other top kids in the 2024 class not receiving an offer, I would at least think we offer 1 or 2 per year so when they commit elsewhere, they can't pull the bs and say we never showed any interest.
I understand this, but why not offer the in-state kid? I am not even talking about the landing part. Still, after hearing the McAndrews interview about not even receiving an offer and other top kids in the 2024 class not receiving an offer, I would at least think we offer 1 or 2 per year so when they commit elsewhere, they can't pull the bs and say we never showed any interest.
I know this can seem frustrating at times when good players from the state seem to be bypassed for others out of state. And while there are many reasons for this, I've seen Wilson play many times, and he's a good all around player. I don't believe at his size and position however, that he has the athleticism and bounce to be an effective Big Ten player. I haven't seem Walker play, but I'm guessing he's more athletic and has a bigger upside than Wilson.I don't want to get in a comparison thing but I'm kind of confused why are we prioritizing this guy who is ranked 2 spots ahead of Jalen Wilson and whose games are eerily similar over Wilson who is from here. It's not like this kid is a game changer any more than Wilson and I thought the point of hiring Ben is to bring in kids from here who are at the top of their class
I can remember when the Gopher coaching staff recruited tall stone masons from Africa.I understand this, but why not offer the in-state kid? I am not even talking about the landing part. Still, after hearing the McAndrews interview about not even receiving an offer and other top kids in the 2024 class not receiving an offer, I would at least think we offer 1 or 2 per year so when they commit elsewhere, they can't pull the bs and say we never showed any interest.
Im not even saying Wilson is a big ten stud but ive both play and they are fairly similar athletically and neither seem to be Wings. I just don’t understand why we are prioritizing Walker & not even interested in WilsonI know this can seem frustrating at times when good players from the state seem to be bypassed for others out of state. And while there are many reasons for this, I've seen Wilson play many times, and he's a good all around player. I don't believe at his size and position however, that he has the athleticism and bounce to be an effective Big Ten player. I haven't seem Walker play, but I'm guessing he's more athletic and has a bigger upside than Wilson.
This is all about getting players who fit your system and who have the kind of athleticism and potential to be solid Big Ten players. Not everyone around here fits that mold. I'd like to see really good players here, and I personally don't care if they're from Minnesota or Alaska.
Why doesn’t it make sense? Gophers don’t see value in him and they’ve seen him play more then any other staff in the countryI agree. I know the Johnson kid from Totino Grace who's deciding this week or next week and has 5 Power 5 schools as a finalist never even heard from the Gopher staff. This doesn't make any sense to me.
Go Gophers!!
What legit HM offer does Wilson have? Your logic makes no sense… offer Wilson why again?Im not even saying Wilson is a big ten stud but ive both play and they are fairly similar athletically and neither seem to be Wings. I just don’t understand why we are prioritizing Walker & not even interested in Wilson
Sounds like a problematic formula...Tough to offer the in state kids. They are the most likely to have seen the product on the court repeatedly and it's better to not waste the time recruiting them.
McAndrews made it perfectly clear he wasn't coming to the U. I do understand your point, but I also don't understand why we even offer these guys we know aren't coming here. I'd rather Grove think/know we liked him more than McAndrews.I understand this, but why not offer the in-state kid? I am not even talking about the landing part. Still, after hearing the McAndrews interview about not even receiving an offer and other top kids in the 2024 class not receiving an offer, I would at least think we offer 1 or 2 per year so when they commit elsewhere, they can't pull the bs and say we never showed any interest.
The theory of Ben Johnson from those that even moderately supported his hiring was that he would clean up on in state recruiting. He'd never coached a game, he'd never been part of a winning program, his supposed deep connections to recruiting Minnesota were his selling point. I hate when people post things like a player "made it clear he wasn't coming to Minnesota" Players commit to coaches. The player made it clear he wasn't going to play for Ben Johnson. To use the most recent example, plenty of kids made it clear they weren't coming to Colorado before Prime Time showed up now all of a sudden they are.I think the top kids staying home consistently won't happen until the Gophers are relevant in the conference again. It's probably more likely Ben can land an out of state kid looking for new scenery, versus an in state kid who knows definitively how irrelevant the program is currently. He's had a reasonably good start getting in-state kids that probably would have gone elsewhere if the previous head coach were here. He needs to win big before we start getting the attention of in-state players with a serious offer sheet.
McAndrews and Freitag both felt slighted because the Gophers weren't there first. I doubt either would have been here regardless but it further pushes the narrative that is floated around, especially in the Metro. I do agree with the statement in boldMcAndrews made it perfectly clear he wasn't coming to the U. I do understand your point, but I also don't understand why we even offer these guys we know aren't coming here. I'd rather Grove think/know we liked him more than McAndrews.
I do get your point but I just don't believe there was ever any interest from them. They wanted Gopher offers for the sole purpose of rejecting us. To hell with that, we're not here to get their announcement more local publicity. Prior to offers, if Frietag or McAndrews would have given any inclination they were interested, I have no doubt we would have offered. Frietag and Asuma could play together and McAndrews and Grove could play together.McAndrews and Freitag both felt slighted because the Gophers weren't there first. I doubt either would have been here regardless but it further pushes the narrative that is floated around, especially in the Metro. I do agree with the statement in bold
False...Freitag...felt slighted because the Gophers weren't there first.
Right now they only have two scholarships for 2024, I know you can assume a couple more are going to open up and over commit or wait until t happens and fill from the portal which is what I believe the Gopher staff is doing. If they aren't going to over commit with high school kids grab the ones you want and who cares about the rest.I do get your point but I just don't believe there was ever any interest from them. They wanted Gopher offers for the sole purpose of rejecting us. To hell with that, we're not here to get their announcement more local publicity. Prior to offers, if Frietag or McAndrews would have given any inclination they were interested, I have no doubt we would have offered. Frietag and Asuma could play together and McAndrews and Grove could play together.
For me, their criticisms feel a little like the BS by guys like Jalen Suggs who were 100% not going to come here. There is an obsession with telling people you were somehow slighted (even when you're the one doing the slighting).