I don't know why Kill/Claeys are in discussion but, despite 8-9 wins, the teams they coached never seemed dangerous (and often seemed incompetent), and that played out by never beating our rivals and by never beating a team that finished the season ranked. Their tenure was not successful.
Actually, I believe Claeys 2016 team may have made an appearance at #25 on the ending coaches' poll (not the AP). Kill/Claeys never beat Wisconsin but they did beat Iowa twice (one time was a total rout) and we haven't beaten Iowa since their second time.
Since Murray Warmath's long tenure that stretched from the fifties to the early seventies, Minnesota's most successful coaches have been:
Fleck: .574
Mason: .529
Kill/Claeys: 519
Of course, Fleck's much better record in a small sample size can be attributed to one great season (.846 winning percentage). Outside of that season, he is 13-14. By the way, despite Murray Warmath's great accomplishments, his overall winning percentage in his long tenure was .526, virtually identical to Mason's.
Fan aspirations are fine but fan aspirations don't amount to a hill of beans when it comes to the success of a given team in a season. All fans can do is show up and give money.
We may get to where you want to be someday but we're not there yet. In the meantime, I'm going to set my expectations to who we are, not who I would like us to be. I would call the Kill/Claeys tenure relatively successful under a realistic appraisal.
Last edited: