I've never understood comments like this. Being critical of someone or something doesn't require intimate knowledge or skill in the area being criticized. I can criticize Dan Bailey all day long and I can't kick a football 20 yards. I've never directed a movie but I can say with absolute certainty that Battlefield Earth was awful. I'm not a rock star but I can state with vigor that Weezer's remake of "Africa" was no good.Now he is a starting OL as RS Frosh on a BIG team. How many here can say that?