Can someone clarify transfer rules, especially within the B1G. The ESPN article says he will have only 2 seasons left. If he played as a true freshman this year, why won't he have 3 seasons remaining if he used his redshirt year this year?
Your question hits on the key issue here - "especially within the B1G." Under NCAA transfer rules, he would have three seasons remaining after redshirting in 2012-13.
However, the Big Ten recently changed its transfer rules, which add a penalty for intraconference transfers - specifically, the loss of one year of competition eligibility. (At the same time, the Big Ten changed its existing rules that didn't allow for the intraconference transfer to be on scholarship for the first year after transfer - they now can receive aid immediately - so, if a scholarship becomes available, Bobek could be all set financially in 2012-13.)
This probably wasn't talked about as much re: Uthoff's transfer from Becky to Iowa because he had redshirted his freshman year at Wisconsin (as opposed to Bobek, who played for tOSU). He effectively loses a year of competition by transferring because of the Five-Year Rule.
So.. the five year path for Bobek could have been:
Transfer to a non-B1G school: PLAY, REDSHIRT, PLAY, PLAY, PLAY
Transfer to a B1g school: PLAY, REDSHIRT(BUT BE CHARGED AS THOUGH PLAYING VIA PENALTY), [3 YEARS LEFT TO PLAY 2 YEARS]
Whereas Uthoff was facing:
Non-B1G: REDSHIRT, REDSHIRT, PLAY, PLAY, PLAY
B1G: REDSHIRT, REDSHIRT(BUT BE CHARGED AS THOUGH PLAYING VIA PENALTY), PLAY, PLAY, PLAY