Frustrating indeed
Basically, I stopped following the Vikings in late November and early December of 1999. Minnesota returned home from Happy Valley with a 6-3 record having having dropped the losses by a combined total of eleven points to ranked opponents in Wisconsin, Ohio State, and Purdue. Replete with it's own "stimulus package," the program came home to a crowd of 47,852 against Indiana (W: 44-20) -- well short of capacity at the Metrodome (or even, TCF Bank Stadium). Quite honestly, this pissed me off!
Originally, I thought that the pent-up demand for a winning season was finally satiated for the first time in nine years, recruiting would turn, and Gopher football would be important to the local sports community again. After reconnecting with friends from the U about the season, it dawned on me how challenging it was going to be. Fast forward four years to 2003 -- a ten win season averaging 44K. BTW - we won 20-14 at Penn State (3-9) again that year in front of 106K+.
I've invested considerable thought into why we seem to be in this position and think there are a number of factors that fit into the equation...
1. Depth of local HS talent base (OK, but more D2/FCS/D3 quality).
2. Local climate (more hype than substance relative to conference).
3. The University community (not the foundation of the collegiate experience as it is elsewhere).
4. Relative popularity of football (Hockey attracts more attention and talent than other places).
5. Importance & priority of the University to the citizenry (many other ed options; pub & prvt).
Not sure what to think...