I take issue with those who want to evaluate Pitino based solely, or largely, on his six-year record. I think one needs to look beyond that to consider what has contributed to that record and whether he shows signs of maturing into a top-level coach. A big factor is the fact that he was not ready to be a Power 6 coach at the time Norwood Teague hired him. He made recruiting errors and they have cost us. His recent recruiting, though, in my opinion, has vastly improved. In terms of his on-court record, in his first season, with inherited talent, he won 25 games and finished 7th in the Big Ten. The next year he won 18 and finished in a 10th place tie, then dropped to 8 wins and 13th place. He then popped back up to 24 wins in the 2016-2017 season and a 4th place Big Ten finish. His fifth season began with great promise and lofty national rankings only to explode with injuries and a crippling suspension. Without the loss of 4 of his top 6 rotation players that year, I believe he would have continued on the trajectory that he began the prior year, and that would have resulted in a stronger showing this year.
There is merit in the contentions of some that there needs to be pressure to achieve at high levels of success, and that, as a fan base, we should not be content with mediocrity. But there is also, in my opinion, a need for program stability to permit it to reach those levels. Constantly starting over is unlikely to be successful. The question is whether Pitino has the potential to take us where we all want to go, and I think he does. I think he is smart, learns quickly, communicates well, and handles adversity and criticism well. I also think he has demonstrated integrity and decency. Long-term, those are the ingredients of a successful coach.