Spurgeon is a really good regular season defenseman but when it gets to the playoffs he gets tossed around like a pinball
Brodin for sure. He's signed through 27-28 and, when healthy, is a top level defensemen. He has been hurt all year. Spurgeon is signed through 26-27. A couple differences in these two - size, as you mention, is significant. Brodin is just as quick and stronger. Brodin's salary is $6MM, vs $7.5MM for Spurgeon. Brodin will turn 31 in July, Spurgeon 35 in November. It doesn't appear Brodin has a no-trade and Spurgeon can submit a 10 team no-trade list on July 1, 2024.
I would try very hard to get some good value for Spurgeon and keep Brodin. But good luck with the former, him being out for the season and a high number. If he plays well at the start of next season, I would shop him again. I'm not saying he's not skilled and an asset. He is. But at what price? Try to get someone to bite who needs stability on the back end.
Jake Middleton - signed through next season at $2.45MM. He's been asked to do too much this season, out of necessity. I think as a 5-6 D, at that price, I would extend a couple more years. He's tough, gritty, improving offense and a team player. Needs to improve significantly on winning puck battles in the D zone and zone exits. Just turned 28 in January.
Bogo - I love what he brings. He is in the final year of his 3 years at $850K/yr contract and just signed a 2 year extension at $1.25MM/yr - what a steal, if he holds up! He is another team player guy - lots of toughness. Good in offensive zone. Good at zone exits. Lots to like. Downside - he turns 34 in July.
One guy not mentioned above is Ryan Hartman. He's in an interesting situation as he currently has a leaguewide no-trade clause that expires at the end of the season. He signed a 3 year @$4MM/yr extension in October. There isn't a no-trade next year. The following, he has a 15 team list and the year after a 10 team list. He's a productive player and gritty as hell. I'm not sure how he is in the lockerroom, but I bet he is polarizing. I could be completely off, but he reminds me of HJ Pierzinski - love him when he's on your team, hate him otherwise. Could be wrong. Guy can score goals though, which we desperately need. And he's another never-gives-up guy. Not sure if I would shop him or not......
Thank you for the amazing 9 years
www.capfriendly.com
Thank you for the amazing 9 years
www.capfriendly.com
Thank you for the amazing 9 years
www.capfriendly.com
Thank you for the amazing 9 years
www.capfriendly.com