PROBLEM #1:
You beat me to this point GopherGrit. This is a huge part of it. I graduated in 1995. I remember going to a couple games with my friends at the Metrodome and the environment was terrible. Getting there was terrible too. Tailgating was basically non-existent. That is why we never went back until they built the current stadium. Even when that happened, it took me years to ever get back into watching the Gophers. I had developed allegiances to other local sporting teams with varying high water marks in level of interest in the Wild, Twins, Vikings, Timberwolves, Gopher hockey and Gopher basketball. As I've started following Gopher football more including spending more and more time on this message board, I've followed those teams less. We lost a lot of fans during those Metrodome years that are now in their prime earning years like me. We'll never get a large portion of them back.
PROBLEM #2:
My impression is Nebraska football is big for almost all Nebraskan's, not just people that went to school there. They are culturally extremely important to the state. Same for Iowa/Iowa State. Those teams are the main sporting entertainment choice for people in those states by far. The Vikings are the main sporting entertainment choice in this state and the U isn't even a close number two, it's way down the list. We are the state of HOCKEY, not football, so the Wild and Gopher hockey are very important. Hockey is not that large a distraction in states south of us. Pro basketball is becoming a bigger draw too (men & women's) as is soccer.
Part of the reason we have all these pro sports teams is because we are the largest metropolitan area northwest of Chicago for quite a long ways! We're a natural hub in this region for pro sports teams and draw pro sports fans from the Dakotas, Iowa and western Wisconsin. That's an awesome thing for the Twin Cities. The problem is that dilutes the importance of the Gophers as sports entertainment. Every dollar spent promoting the Gophers is drowned out by dollars spent on all our other pro sports teams. Unfortunately, those same cross border pro sports fans have local choices for college teams. That puts dollars into the pockets of pro sports teams that the Gophers do not have access to. An Iowa fan can easily be a Viking fan, but they are much less likely to be a Gopher fan. Those pro sports teams advertise with those dollars which directly hurts the Gophers. The U of M draws mostly alum and I don't see that changing. The Gophers are not a state institution the same way our competitors are. The Badgers are in a closer situation since Wisconsin has a lot of pro sports teams, but Wisconsin seems to put more effort behind being a Badger state. Wisconsin's state medical program is called Badger Care for god's sake! Talk about free advertising. I don't think we'll ever get that level of support from our state. Too many other distractions. Even in the Twin Cities, it seems like St. Thomas is not as far behind the Gophers in notoriety as they should be.
PROBLEM #3:
The Gophers had a LONG run of being not very good. If they were better more recently, that would certainly have helped, but I don't see that ever completely overcoming #2 above. We're blessed to have all these sports entertainment choices in the metro, but it hurts the Gophers. Yes, our population is larger than other surrounding metros, but not so much so that it overcomes all of our sporting choices. The Gophers being good IS helping with #1, but that will take time.
I love being a fan of the Gophers! They are a great comparative value and the tailgating and game day atmosphere is improving. I think their overall situation will continue to improve. Thank god we are in the Big Ten Conference and all the money that brings!!! I also think it's unrealistic to overestimate our upside. Some of the positives of the Twin Cities sports entertainment scene are a permanent negative for the Gophers.