I’ll defer to
@mngg11 reply and dutifully await
your analysis.
Let’s actually see if the West Coast is the best Coast
MNgg11 likes to call people who have a different opinion names, and doesn't like me because I have the audacity to be critical of Fleck, so I don't pay too much attention to what he has to say.
I have not said a lot of things that have been inferred from my post, some of which I have not said at all, and some of which is due to my phrasing.
When I said line development I was referring to the consistency of results game to game and season to season of the line, not individual players. I was not clear there, so that's on me.
Early in Fleck's tenure, the O-line was a mess (based on the roster when he arrived). He brought in some talented players, so I'm not saying that we haven't had players, but the lines have historically not had a good season, then the next year have a better season when there was continuity. E.G., not saying the 2019 line wasn't better than the 2017 line.
I have also not seen the olines show significant improvement from game 2 to game 12, with the possible exception of 2019.
Last season was the poster child for the lack of development year to year and from game one to game 12.
Using yds per attempt as a measure, 2023 showed a 3.4 yds per carry average in B1G conf games. 2024 was 3.56 yds per carry in B1G conf games. This is with a significantly better QB under center and a healthy DT for most of the games vs Jordan Nubin as the feature back due to the significant injuries in 2023.
Another factor is sacks. The line gave up 17 sacks in B1G games in both seasons, even though AK was more prone to holding the ball too long and taking sacks needlessly, whereas Max didn't suffer that same affliction and was adept at getting rid of the ball when in trouble.
One of the reasons I looked at B1G games is that the bulk of the B1G season is after a few games - although in 2023 Nebbie was our first game.
I do expect this years line will be better than game one, but the play was eerily similar to last years game one and based on the lack of significant improvement during the course of the season last year, the lack of history of the line together this year, and 8 years of similar results, I'm not optimistic that we'll see a marked improvement over the course of the season.
My question was an honest request to understand your perspective. I am interested to learn what makes you feel differently beyond the whole PJ Fleck can do no wrong, and anyone who DARES question anything about him is full of BS from the likes of MNgg11 and similar posters.
There's a lot I see, but you disagree with my take away, so maybe I'm missing something, so if your so inclined, I'd like to understand what you see to balance
my opinion based on what I see.
And if your not inclined, so be it.
ps I left Cali to go to the U and never returned living in the Midwest and Texas ever since, so I won't claim to speak for the left coast.