Why not us .... wheres our curt cignetti

[Lifeleadership]

You win with great players, great coaches and a financial backing to support both of these needs. At Minnesota, we need to rely heavily on developing HS recruits. We don't have the money to buy a great roster. So, we develop great players and grab a few great players in the portal to fill the gaps and develop better depth.

Then create a system and process to get you where you want to go. With a high level of "buy in" to that system, great players have a better chance of maximizing their full potential which leads to
a team that gets the results they are striving for.

At the end of the day, you need a financial commitment from the University to be able to provide the resources to bring in great players and keep great coaches.

Listen to what the President of Indiana shared with the world. They have a very intense finacial commitment to their Football Program which is producing great results.

It certainly doesn't hurt to have a Mark Cuban in your corner.

 

[PMWinSTP]

You win with great players, great coaches and a financial backing to support both of these needs. At Minnesota, we need to rely heavily on developing HS recruits. We don't have the money to buy a great roster. So, we develop great players and grab a few great players in the portal to fill the gaps and develop better depth.

Then create a system and process to get you where you want to go. With a high level of "buy in" to that system, great players have a better chance of maximizing their full potential which leads to
a team that gets the results they are striving for.

At the end of the day, you need a financial commitment from the University to be able to provide the resources to bring in great players and keep great coaches.

Listen to what the President of Indiana shared with the world. They have a very intense finacial commitment to their Football Program which is producing great results.

It certainly doesn't hurt to have a Mark Cuban in your corner.

Go look at IU's and the U's overall classes for 2025 and 2026. They are very similar. Go look at Cignetti's 2024 pay, and the pay of his staff. He was making close to $3 million less than Fleck. Did they get an influx of $$ for 2025? Yes, absolutely. Did it translate into bringing in a bunch of highly rated recruits and transfers that impacted 2025? Other than the QB, I do not think so. IU's overall class for 2025 was ranked #39, the U's was ranked #43. IU's 2026 overall class is ranked #23 (39 total, 10 4*), the U's is ranked #29 (50 total, 7 4*) so there is more separation in this class than the previous two (2024, 2025) as far as rating talent.

I do agree there's a difference in coaching and developing players, no question.

 

[beavergopher]

Our Cignetti coaches the Dance Line.

 

[Some guy]

If anybody here knows where the next Cignetti is, they should point him out. The question isn't where is he; the real question is who is he.

Who is this Cignetti-level (2-for-2 playoff participant, national champion) coach available to take over the Gophers program right now?

If fleck left the gophers I would go all in on Ferris state coach

Offensive innovator
Kind of old.
But wins.
Midwest ties.

If he doesn’t work out you start fresh in 3 years


Super unconventional hire to jump d2 to the big ten.
Tressel was Youngstown to Ohio state

 

[Lifeleadership]

Go look at IU's and the U's overall classes for 2025 and 2026. They are very similar. Go look at Cignetti's 2024 pay, and the pay of his staff. He was making close to $3 million less than Fleck. Did they get an influx of $$ for 2025? Yes, absolutely. Did it translate into bringing in a bunch of highly rated recruits and transfers that impacted 2025? Other than the QB, I do not think so. IU's overall class for 2025 was ranked #39, the U's was ranked #43. IU's 2026 overall class is ranked #23 (39 total, 10 4*), the U's is ranked #29 (50 total, 7 4*) so there is more separation in this class than the previous two (2024, 2025) as far as rating talent.

I do agree there's a difference in coaching and developing players, no question.

If Indiana had the U of M money for the assistant coaches pay, would they be able to keep those assistants around after the 2024 season? Maybe those assistants don't care about the money but I believe that is the challenge the U is facing with the turnover of coaches. Signetti always talks about how important it is that his coaches have been with him for a while.

Rankings don't always tell the full story. Indiana had the best QB in the country (1st Team B10), two 2nd team WR's, 1st Team Tackle, 3rd Team Guard, 3rd team Tight End, 1st Team DLineman, 1st Team LB, 2nd Team LB, two 1st Team DB's and 5 Honorable Mention All-Big 10.

Great players and obviously great coaching. To me, it takes money to keep great players and keep great coaches. I think Fleck does a heck of a job with what he has to financially work with. I believe Fleck is the best coach we have had in my 50 years as a Gopher fan. Just my opinion. Do I want the Gophers to be able to experience the CFB playoffs? Absolutely! Then Fleck needs the financial backing to be able to keep his great coaches and attract the great players.

I agree, Minnesota has to be developmental program. I love what PJ does with the program. We have an opportunity to be really good in 2026. Go Gophers!

 

[RememberMurray]

If fleck left the gophers I would go all in on Ferris state coach

Offensive innovator
Kind of old.
But wins.
Midwest ties.

If he doesn’t work out you start fresh in 3 years


Super unconventional hire to jump d2 to the big ten.
Tressel was Youngstown to Ohio state

Re: the bold italics...
It sounds as though you prefer the Wisconsin approach — keep firing coaches until you win a championship — over the Iowa approach — stick with a coach who has consistently produced a solid result.

Iowa finished number 17 in the final poll yesterday. Wisconsin didn't even make a "meaningless" bowl game.

I assume you'd fire Fickell; would you fire Ferentz?

 

[Some guy]

Re: the bold italics...
It sounds as though you prefer the Wisconsin approach — keep firing coaches until you win a championship — over the Iowa approach — stick with a coach who has consistently produced a solid result.

Iowa finished number 17 in the final poll yesterday. Wisconsin didn't even make a "meaningless" bowl game.

I assume you'd fire Fickell; would you fire Ferentz?

I wouldn’t fire Ferentz or fleck
I would fire Fickell

You should always fire a coach ASAP when you’re confident they can’t make another run.
i think a run now constitutes a 10 win season. Ferentz or fleck could still do that IMO


I am not super sold on fleck. Two years in a row I’ve entered the season thinking it was possible I’d want him gone before the end of the year.
I’ve stated on this board if he left on his own it might be good for both parties.
But I would’ve give him next year an analyze from there

 

[RememberMurray]

Andy Reid was 130-93 in Philadelphia, with a 10-9 record in the playoffs in 9 playoff appearances, 0-1 in the Super Bowl. The Eagles fired him.

Reid went to Kansas City, and we know how that has turned out.

Is Reid a good, bad or mediocre coach?

 

[Some guy]

Andy Reid was 130-93 in Philadelphia, with a 10-9 record in the playoffs in 9 playoff appearances, 0-1 in the Super Bowl. The Eagles fired him.

Reid went to Kansas City, and we know how that has turned out.

Is Reid a good, bad or mediocre coach?

He’s a great coach.
Both he and Philly have had more superbowl success since he left Philly

 

[RememberMurray]

I wouldn’t fire Ferentz or fleck
I would fire Fickell

You should always fire a coach ASAP when you’re confident they can’t make another run.
i think a run now constitutes a 10 win season. Ferentz or fleck could still do that IMO


I am not super sold on fleck. Two years in a row I’ve entered the season thinking it was possible I’d want him gone before the end of the year.
I’ve stated on this board if he left on his own it might be good for both parties.
But I would’ve give him next year an analyze from there

I agree with most of this.

I don't think you fire a coach simply because he hasn't achieved what Cignetti has. That's a ridiculously high bar. If you're disappointed every time your team fails to make the 12 team playoff bracket, or fails to win the National Championship, you are almost certainly going to spend your fandom in a constant state of disgruntlement. I can't and won't live my life like that.

 

[Some guy]

I agree with most of this.

I don't think you fire a coach simply because he hasn't achieved what Cignetti has. That's a ridiculously high bar. If you're disappointed every time your team fails to make the 12 team playoff bracket, or fails to win the National Championship, you are almost certainly going to spend your fandom in constant state of disgruntlement. I can't and won't live my life like that.

Agree.

 

[btowngopher]

Go look at IU's and the U's overall classes for 2025 and 2026. They are very similar. Go look at Cignetti's 2024 pay, and the pay of his staff. He was making close to $3 million less than Fleck. Did they get an influx of $$ for 2025? Yes, absolutely. Did it translate into bringing in a bunch of highly rated recruits and transfers that impacted 2025? Other than the QB, I do not think so. IU's overall class for 2025 was ranked #39, the U's was ranked #43. IU's 2026 overall class is ranked #23 (39 total, 10 4*), the U's is ranked #29 (50 total, 7 4*) so there is more separation in this class than the previous two (2024, 2025) as far as rating talent.

I do agree there's a difference in coaching and developing players, no question.

Not sure I’m ready to crown Cignetti as a master developer when a lot of the success was due to transfer players. Plus he’s only been there two years. Yes they’ve developed some good ones as well, but not sure that is the big difference between him and other coaches. Also it’s hard to distinguish between having an eye for talent and developing talent, but I think with Cig his eye for talent and fit is what separates him from others.