I went to a couple games at the dome back when I was a student in the 90's. It sucked and it was BECAUSE it wasn't on campus, not because the dome was old, at least to me. I just don't think a shiny new stadium would have mattered much. You've got to have the stadium on campus. Location, Location, Location! The feel is SOOO much better now. The two are not even comparable. The U lost a whole generation of fans to that move. Some of us are slowly trickling back. Another thing I hate now that I'm older is downtown Minneapolis and I don't think I'm alone. Having the stadium away from downtown is a huge plus for many of us.
UCLA will have to have a really good football team for a long time to make a location 12 miles from campus matter. I agree with Maxy that it's likely better, but still not good. What a mess they have on their hands.
Question: Is there an example of a stadium that is NOT on campus that is awesome? I've been to very few so may well not know what I'm talking about. If yes, is there an example of a stadium 12 MILES from campus?