Sara Scalia enters the transfer portal

My concern since day 1 is who LW surrounded herself with. I knew there was going to be a major learning curve. I accepted that and was ok with that and still am. However, I question the assistants that were hired. Young with no great track record. Certainly no great head coaching experience from assistants. IMO she needed older experienced coaches surrounding her. Coaches who may have admired her as a player, but had the experience to offset her lack of experience. While nice people, the assistants have never had proven winning track records as head coaches at any level that I am aware of. Did Shimmy have a winning season at St. Louis? What was Royslands record at Macalaster? I don't think she even achieved a 500% season at a D3 school did she? What about Carly? Has she even had head coaching experience? She has a great bloodline and will probably get a shot at a head coach spot down the road, and probably would have been a nice assistant had we initially had a stronger supporting staff. Even O'Banion in the first year had a brutal head coaching record at Kent State previously I believe. If LW isn't able to turn this program around, I think this will be what brings her coaching tenure at the U down. Thoughts?
She hired assistants that had a strong background and had a variety of experience coaching. This is on Lindsey for her inability to manage the team and Coyle for hiring her when she wasn’t ready.
 

Appreciate your follow up. No change in opinion, in fact probably strengthened what I had thought. Some solid assistant coaching tenors for our assistants, but no solid head coaching winning experience even for Shimmy from what my limited research found. I agree with what you said about Carly, but again, she was most likely a tag along on the Schaefer lead teams that were already really good prior to her joining the staff versus the reason those teams won. She was what, the 3rd or 4th assistant on those teams. Her dad is great (heck he's basically Bball royalty) and her husband appears do be doing a really great job also. No doubt she has a bright future and could have been a great 3rd or 4th assistant coach in year one on LW's staff if we had a more solid #2 Asst coach. She's a positive pedigreed up and comer. When I was talking about winning experience, I was really referring to that of being a head coach. I would have preferred finding a top notch #2 Asst coach with a winning D1 head coaching track record, if even for just 1 season, not a track record of losing over multiple seasons at the D1 level, let alone D3 level. I don't know that we hired an Asst coach that even had a winning regular season record at any level of college basketball did we? Maybe those types of Asst coaches just don't exist and I'm wrong.
What successful HCs would come here to be a MN assistant coach under a coach with no experience? If they have a winning HC record they are still a HC.
 



Curious to why this matters?
When former players reach out to you and say good things about you, then you get the impression Jaz didnt leave because she hated playing with Sara.
Many here say they werent a big fan of Jaz and we could see why at times, but she WAS talented, that talent has to be shaped and molded from day 1. I wouldnt be surprised if she is solid at TN.
 



This statement resonated..
"Sara has big dreams and only so much time to tackle them."

Loyalty could be a concern for us old timers, but kids today have a vision more so then 30 years ago. In a team sport you rely on your coaches to bring that vision to reality. Not blaming the coaches, it can be bad luck, it can be an injury, it can be a lot of things, but at the end of the day for whatever reason this program is not in position to put a winning product on the floor(as of todays roster) and as much as it hurts, you respect her decision to move on.
I'm sure Sara had some resentment losing 10+ players with eligibility left over the years, Kadi might of been the dagger.
 

Hopefully Coyle, Whalen, her staff, and the players are doing much self-examination today.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MRJ

Hopefully Coyle, Whalen, her staff, and the players are doing much self-examination today.
Hopefully they do that regardless because all successful people are reflective imo. This should sting more, but Coyle is pretty on top of this stuff and Whalen was on notice already.
 



Not a good look with the Women's final four in town for the Gophers women's basketball program to be disintegrating and having your perceived best player leaving.
 

Maybe the friends are better coaches then Whalen?
I tend to agree here. The kids are not seeing a light at the end of the tunnel as far as winning and progress and the vision from the head coach. All you had to do was watch even the early tournament games in the NCAA's to see how far away everything is from turning a corner. Both Carly and Kelly, and Shimmy are all good coaches, you can see it in the communication style during games. In fact this team played it's best games of the previous year with Carly at the helm, so much more relaxed, and not the pinched nickels between the butt cheeks on the floor like when Whalen was on the sideline. There must be a reason for this to have occured. This is a trust and communication problem with with the head coach on player development. Wanting to win and being able to teach it and have the kids learn it, is a whole different prospect than playing the game. The tension and communication problems seem to be real.
 

Whalen isn't fit to be a coach
Every interview I hear leads me to believe this, super nice and a legend as a player but lacks the "it" from a coaching perspective.
 
Last edited:

Players will pro aspirations are just as likely to be discovered playing at Podunk U as they are at UConn. If you are prospective pro, they will turn over every rock to find you.
That’s a naive point of view.
 





Appears the possibility of four recruiting visits this weekend without leaving home.
Scalia? She wouldn't start or play more than 15 minutes for these four teams if that is what you mean. Maybe it's her teammates bringing her down as that is what she is saying by leaving.
 


I think it is pretty basic: 1. You gotta have fun playing a game you love!!! If you don’t think a coach can help make you and your teammates better. Well, then there is no hope and the answer is to find it someplace else where the coach will help you win. And the game can be fun again! Despair puts you in the portal.
2. If you watch our defense as a team and see our offensive schemes…I’m not sure anyone could be optimistic it will improve.
So, players have doubt. The answers they get are empty. So they leave.

I do not see it improving to a consistently winning program under Lindsay no matter how bad she wants to win. She’s a competitor supreme and maybe her frustration is evident because her players don’t live up to her standards/expectations.
She just doesn’t seem to have the personality to be a coach. Her street cred is/was as a player…there’s nothing to point to as a coach.
 


Every interview I hear leads me to believe this, super nice and a legend as a player but lacks the "it" from a coaching perspective.
Part of the 'it' factor is having a vision of how the team is going to play and hanging your hat on that vision. You recruit to that, you train to that, and, eventually, you hope to be successful with that. I don't remember hearing a vision articulated by Coach and I have not seen it find its way to the hardwood.

Even Stollings had a vision about her offense being a defense or some gobblydeedoo like that.
 

This really hurts. Something is seriously wrong with the program and the university should be doing exit interviews, or if they already do that, they should fix the problem ASAP.
 

This has been all brewing since Destiny Pitts was suspended and left the program. Something is up in the Gophers women's basketball program. This cannot just be a players issues or players problem. Something is not right with how the head coach Whalen is handling things. There is more to this story than just winning and wanting to win. We will probably never know.
 

This has been all brewing since Destiny Pitts was suspended and left the program. Something is up in the Gophers women's basketball program. This cannot just be a players issues or players problem. Something is not right with how the head coach Whalen is handling things. There is more to this story than just winning and wanting to win. We will probably never know.
Or maybe since all of these players were here when Pitts left, it’s better to just clean the entire house?
 

Regardless of the reasons why 4 players have entered the portal the issue rest with the coach.
Tell that to the hundreds of mens and woman's programs who have experienced the same issue. In 2020 there were 490 female athletes in the portal. The number jumped to over a thousand in 2021 and as of the end of March there were almost 900 in this seasons portal. I have supported Whalen since her high school days but am not blind to the multiple deficits of her teams. She has signed an extension and will have the opportunity to coach the highest recruiting class the program has ever had in it's history. There are recent examples of winning teams; Kentucky, MD, AZ and today ND lost 3 transfers and we know some of these teams have very successful highly ranked coaches. The portal is a reality and I am hoping we can get some more talent for next season.
 


WOW, everybody needs to take a step back,Whalen might not ever figure it out but it's way to early to be pulling the plug on her coaching career. There's a halfways decent coach in New England that had a losing record 5 out of his 6 first seasons..................
 


WOW, everybody needs to take a step back,Whalen might not ever figure it out but it's way to early to beU pulling the plug on her coaching career. There's a halfways decent coach in New England that had a losing record 5 out of his 6 first seasons..................

UM...

1985-86 12-154-12--
1986-8714-139-7--
1987-8817-119-7--
1988-8924-613-2NCAA First Round
 

Tell that to the hundreds of mens and woman's programs who have experienced the same issue. In 2020 there were 490 female athletes in the portal. The number jumped to over a thousand in 2021 and as of the end of March there were almost 900 in this seasons portal. I have supported Whalen since her high school days but am not blind to the multiple deficits of her teams. She has signed an extension and will have the opportunity to coach the highest recruiting class the program has ever had in it's history. There are recent examples of winning teams; Kentucky, MD, AZ and today ND lost 3 transfers and we know some of these teams have very successful highly ranked coaches. The portal is a reality and I am hoping we can get some more talent for next season.

If you lose the nucleus of your team and you've had a succession of losing years and your only hope is the unproven potential of new recurits why would a 4 or 5 star player, in the portal, choose MN?
 





Top Bottom