It's one thing to criticize Weber's flaws, but some of the personal shots I see taken at him on this board tend to turn my stomach and are totally out of line in my opinion. This young man is not a highly paid professional, he's a fricken college player, and people should keep that in mind. It seems there's all this resentment towards him because he continues to start rather than one of his understudies so that we might get a look at the possible future, but he's not the one making that call. It's his coaches who continue to start him.
I have nothing against Weber and I applaud the fact he's always worked hard and played hard and done his best, but to me he will go down in Gopher history as being one of our bigger disappointments, in spite of all his impressive stats. Just based on how he looked and how he played his freshman season, I felt the sky was the limit for that kid, and imagining his career arc back then from his freshman to his senior season- it was like DAMN. If this guy is this heady and this good already, by the time he's a senior he's going to be absolutely AWESOME, and of course that never happened. Rather than progressing as a player, it seemed he plateaued his freshman season and then began a steady regression, and whether that was a result of the rotating coordinators and offensive philosophies, Coach Brewster, Weber himself or all of the above, it seems pretty clear that he undeniably regressed and never matched the potential he showed during that freshman season.
I mean look at the accolades he received that year and his accomplishments as a freshman QB starting in the Big Ten, and it's some really impressive stuff. Third team freshman All American, first team freshman All Big Ten, started all 12 games, completed 57.5% of his passes and threw for 24 TDs including TD passes in 11 of 12 games, set school single-season records for pass completions, attempts, yards and touchdown passes, led the team in rushing with 617 yards on 146 carries and scored 5 rushing TD's to tie for the team lead, set school records for both total offensive yards (3,512) and plays (595), averaged 292.7 yards of total offense per game to rank 20th in the country, third in the Big Ten and first among freshmen nationally, he also finished among the national leaders in points responsible for (14.83 per game), ranking 20th in the NCAA, second in the Big Ten and second among all freshmen nationally, and he was an Academic All Big Ten selection.
Really, I felt like we were seeing the birth of a major star with all that, and had such great hopes and expectations for him as a result of that. It's just a shame that that appeared to be his peak, with the rest of his Gophers career being a slow slide downward into an inconsistent QB with an unreliable arm, and just a shadow of all that terrific promise he'd shown as a freshman.