The Storied Rivalry

TheMonsignor

New member
Joined
Sep 29, 2009
Messages
24
Reaction score
0
Points
1
(Hello Gophers! I post a similar message every year, but for some reason the Hole will no longer recognize the Monsignor. Thus, I've taken the alternative moniker of TheRightReverend. Nonetheless, I look forward to our biennial trip to the Twin Cities and really look forward to seeing the new stadium.)

(Good luck Saturday, but, On Wisconsin !)

THE STORIED RIVALRY.


It is, of course, the most-played rivalry in Division I-A football: 118 meetings and counting, missing only 1906 since that first game in 1890. It was once for the Slab Of Bacon, and since WW 2, has been played for Paul Bunyan's Axe. Minnie leads the series, 59-51-8.

For a lot of old-timers like me, it is THE game of the season. I frankly want to win this game more than any other. A victory over the Gophers can salvage a 1-10 season; it can be the caviar on a Big Ten championship.

The Storied Rivalry moves into a new era this year, as outdoor football returns to the Minnesota campus for the first time since 1981. All I can say is: It’s about time !! I am very excited to see the new TCF Cashbox Stadium. I can only hope that this first game follows the other bookends: In 1981, the last Badger-Gopher game in old Memorial Stadium, Wisconsin won, 26-21. In 1983, the first Wisconsin-Minnesota game in the HHH Uglydome, Wisconsin won, 56-17. Two years ago, in the final game at the Hump, Sconnie beat Minnie, 41-34. I’m hoping for a similar result when Saturday’s game inaugurates the new Gopher Stadium to the Storied Rivalry.

I suggest below some of the more exciting, important or noteworthy games in this rivalry. At the end, I will tell you my favorite.

1. 1890: UM-63, UW-0. What a way to start.

2. 1894: UW-6, UM-0. Badgers secure their first win in the series.

3. 1905: UW-16, UM-12. The Badgers greatest coach of all time, Phil King, ends his career with a 6-2 record against the Gophers, beginning to even out the series. In those games, the UW outscored UM 132-29, and in the 4 games from 1896-99, King's great teams outscored Minnie, 93-0.

4. 1906: For the only time, the two teams did not meet. I blame Teddy Roosevelt.

5. 1917: UW-10, UM-7. Official opening of the new Camp Randall stadium.

6. 1925: UW-12, UM-12. The teams tie for the third straight year.

7. 1933: UM-14, UW-0. This year commences a tradition that will continue to 1982: the UW and UM meet in the final game of the season. In addition, this year starts the great UM domination for nearly two decades. UW will not beat UM for 9 years, until the great Badger team of '42 breaks the skein. UM goes 15-2 in this era.

8. 1961: UW-23, UM-21. Despite the loss, the Gophers earn their last trip to the Rose Bowl. Something about OSU upholding their high academic standards. It was Minnesota’s only Big Ten loss of the year, and the Goofs missed a 2-point conversion in an attempt to tie the game.

9. 1962: UW-14, UM-9. In a battle of titans (ranked #3 and #5), the Badgers win the Rose Bowl trip, helped by some controversial calls by the refs.

10. 1966: UW-7, UM-6. Milt Bruhn wins in his final game, as the crowd chants "Goodbye, Miltie."

11. 1974: UW-49, UM-14. Billy Marek goes wild for 305 yards and 5 TDS in one of the most entertaining games ever at Camp Randall.

12. 1979: UW-42, UM-37. My first visit to old Memorial Stadium in Minneapolis (that I can recall, anyway), with a big snowstorm the night before, Mike “The Polish Rifle” Kalasmiki actually running for a TD, and the Badgers winning only because they had the ball last in a game with two nonexistent defenses.

13. 1981: UW-26, UM-21. Randy Wright's pass to Michael 'Nunchuks' Jones in the corner of the end zone at Memorial sends the UW to its first bowl game since 1963.

14: 1983: UW-56, UM-17. First game in the Dome. A Badger party.

15. 1984: UM-17, UW-14. In the foggie at Camp Randall, Rickey Foggie completes 2 of 21 passes for 218 yards and 3 TDS (or so it seemed at the time) in a big upset.

16: 1991: UW-19, UM-16. BA's first Big Ten win, on the road. Tucker makes the big hit to save the game.

17. 1993: UM-28, UW-21. In the Badgers’ Rose Bowl year, the Gophers ruin a shot at the national championship. Bevell throws for the UW record of 423 yards, but turnovers and a game UM team spell doom. From this game comes the famous quote from the Tipper: "They ain't gonna win another game!"

18. 1999: UW-20, UM-17. OT FG gives UW a heart-thumping win in the Dome, on its way to the Rose Bowl.

19. 2003: UM-37, UW-34. The Gophers repay the favor by winning on a FG on the last play of the game in the Dome.

20. 2005: UW-38, UM-34. UM’s Maroney gashes the UW for nearly 300 yards rushing. But, in one of the most incredible finishes in the Storied Rivalry, the UW overcomes a 10 point deficit in the last 4 minutes, with a blocked punt recovered in the end zone for the winning score with half a minute to play. The Minneapolis crowd is stunned.

21. 2007: UW-41, UM-34. In another track meet, UW’s Brown rushes for 250 yards and UM’s Weber throws for over 350. This game is significant because it is the final game played in that hole of a football stadium, the HHH Metrodome. UW ends up with a 7-6 lead over UM in games played in the Dome.

The Badgers have won 12 of the last 14 games (including 5 in a row) to begin to bring the series closer, and close the gap created by Minnesota’s great teams from the 1930’s – 1950’s.

There you have it. Add on. Argue. But most of all, enjoy one of the best rivalries in college football.

My favorite game: the 1979 track meet in old Memorial Stadium. I could wax at length as to why that is so good, but I will spare you.

ON WISCONSIN!! BEAT MINNESOTA!!!
 

Monsignor....

I so look forward to your annual posts. So sorry to hear that your moniker is no longer recognized. The new one doesn't have quite the same effect.

You represent all that is good about this rivalry. It's intense and we both love to win (and see the other lose), but we both pull for our historic football programs, love our excellent state universities, and reside in tremendous states.

May your first visit to our new home be a memorable one with a great game. I also hope you have a long trip home sans Paul Bunyan's Axe.
 

Great post as usual TheRightReverend - good stuff as usual.

Rivalries are what makes sports fun and it's great having your historical knowledge on GH each year. Thanks for stopping by and let's hope we add another memorable chapter to the nations longest running rivalry!

Go Gophers!!
 


Thank you monsignor, much appreciated. I'm just wondering because you obviously have spent much time on this; has wisconsin always sucked as much as they do now. Or is this a recent thing.
 



first year reading this post. great job it makes for a pretty good yarn.
 

Welcome back, Monsignor!

I was wondering when you were gonna pop back in!

Thanks for keeping the spirit and tradition of the rivalry alive!:)
 

if your going to keep putting Minny and Goofs in there...

where is Fadgers, Cheesedicks and Hell?
 



They changed it! I love Gopherhole!
 

15. 1984: UM-17, UW-14. In the foggie at Camp Randall, Rickey Foggie completes 2 of 21 passes for 218 yards and 3 TDS (or so it seemed at the time) in a big upset.

Nice post. One comment: #15 - Rickey Foggie must have been a monster! 2 passes for 218 yards and 3 TDs! 3 TDs with a score of 17 doesn't add up either.
 

One Game You May Have Overlooked

Loved the post.

Despite your being a Wisconsin fan, I thank you for managing to include many memorable Gopher wins. But one game that I would also love to see remembered was the 1971 game won by the Gophers 23-21. Neither a Big Ten title or a New Year's Day Bowl were on the line, but it turned out to be Coach Murray Warmath's last harrah. Although he had not told anyone, Warmath knew that this was likely his last game as coach as he was more or less getting forced out. Gophers scored 2 TDs in the final 2 minutes to pull out a dramatic come-from-behind-victory sending Murray out a winner.

(On the other hand, how you could forget to include 1928 game, won by Minnesota 6-0 which prevented Wisconsin from the Big Ten title? Supposedly it was Bronko Nagurski's best game as a collegian.)
 

Great post Monsignor!

Thanks for that - it was a great read!
 



Great post, Padre. Nice to have you on board.
 

Loved the post.

Despite your being a Wisconsin fan, I thank you for managing to include many memorable Gopher wins. But one game that I would also love to see remembered was the 1971 game won by the Gophers 23-21. Neither a Big Ten title or a New Year's Day Bowl were on the line, but it turned out to be Coach Murray Warmath's last harrah. Although he had not told anyone, Warmath knew that this was likely his last game as coach as he was more or less getting forced out. Gophers scored 2 TDs in the final 2 minutes to pull out a dramatic come-from-behind-victory sending Murray out a winner.

(On the other hand, how you could forget to include 1928 game, won by Minnesota 6-0 which prevented Wisconsin from the Big Ten title? Supposedly it was Bronko Nagurski's best game as a collegian.)

Thanks, cemba, those are worth adding to the list for next year. I was unaware of the legendary Warmath's last game as coach, but it certainly is worth mentioning.

The 1928 game must have been rough on Badger coach "Gloomy" Glen Thistlewaite. Glen was rarely known to break his frown, and his 7-1-1 1928 team was probably his best. That was the year the UW beat Knute Rockne's Notre Dame team in the fabled "long grass" game at Camp Randall. Rockne claime that the UW didn't mow the field for over a week to slow down his faster Irish squad. Gloomy Glen didn't deny the claim; for the only time in his career, he just smiled.
 

Nice post. One comment: #15 - Rickey Foggie must have been a monster! 2 passes for 218 yards and 3 TDs! 3 TDs with a score of 17 doesn't add up either.

The other amazing Rickie Foggie statistic is that he was QB for the Gophers for at least eight years, by my recollection. I still have nightmares about Foggie before every UW-UM game. You may have had better quarterbacks, but none that scorched the Badgers like Foggie, at least in my memory.
 

1904 Wisconsin

I'm looking for a 1904 performance when we went 13-0 and set the scoring record by outscoring our opponents 725-12. But most importantly, we put up 1,183 yards of offense against Wisconsin alone!!
 

Old monikers have disappeared, which sucks.

For instance, my buddy Gutter Helmet can't log on!
 

What if we create a rumor that Minnesota and Wisconsin really did play in 1906, but played in secret? Of course, they couldn't know at the time how epic this rivalry would be...
 

Gotta love the 1904 schedule! Thankfully we get USC and Texas over the next years.

09/17/1904* Twin Cities Central High Northrop Field • Minneapolis, MN W 107-0
09/24/1904* South Dakota Northrop Field • Minneapolis, MN W 77-0
09/28/1904* Shattuck Northrop Field • Minneapolis, MN W 75-0
10/01/1904* Carleton Northrop Field • Minneapolis, MN W 65-0
10/05/1904* St. Thomas Northrop Field • Minneapolis, MN W 47-0
10/08/1904* North Dakota Northrop Field • Minneapolis, MN W 35-0
10/15/1904* Iowa State Northrop Field • Minneapolis, MN W 32-0
10/22/1904* Grinnell Northrop Field • Minneapolis, MN W 146-0
10/29/1904* Nebraska Northrop Field • Minneapolis, MN W 16-12
11/05/1904* Lawrence Northrop Field • Minneapolis, MN W 69-0
11/12/1904 Wisconsin Northrop Field • Minneapolis, MN W 28-0
11/19/1904 at Northwestern Sheppard Field • Evanston, IL W 17-0
11/24/1904 at Iowa Iowa Field • Iowa City, IA W 11-0
 

I like how the first 11 games are home, and the last two away. I have a feeling that travel was a little more taxing then than it is now.
 

That's one thing I love about football, the passion for the history of the game. If you look at the schedules at gophersports.com, for football, you can look up every year's schedule back to 1890. With basketball, it only goes back to 1977. Basketball is a fine sport, but it doesn't have the same love of history that football does. Probably because the football of over 100 years ago is still recognizable, basketball rule changes changed the game even more radically than football rules have changed it.

The University of Minnesota doesn't claim a national championship for the 1904 season. But the Billingsley Report (whatever that is) has us as national champion for that season. 12 points from the Holy Grail of College football: undefeated, untied and unscored upon, that speaks for itself. Two games over 100 points, six games over 60 points. Only one game where the opponent even scored. Whether there is "official" credit for a national championship, the 1904 season speaks for itself. Amazing that we can look back at a season from over a century ago and get this inspired by it.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NCAA_Division_I_FBS_National_Football_Championship
http://www.cfrc.com/Archives/NC_Team_2008.htm
 

If we were Alabama or Notre Dumb...

That's one thing I love about football, the passion for the history of the game. If you look at the schedules at gophersports.com, for football, you can look up every year's schedule back to 1890. With basketball, it only goes back to 1977. Basketball is a fine sport, but it doesn't have the same love of history that football does. Probably because the football of over 100 years ago is still recognizable, basketball rule changes changed the game even more radically than football rules have changed it.

The University of Minnesota doesn't claim a national championship for the 1904 season. But the Billingsley Report (whatever that is) has us as national champion for that season. 12 points from the Holy Grail of College football: undefeated, untied and unscored upon, that speaks for itself. Two games over 100 points, six games over 60 points. Only one game where the opponent even scored. Whether there is "official" credit for a national championship, the 1904 season speaks for itself. Amazing that we can look back at a season from over a century ago and get this inspired by it.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NCAA_Division_I_FBS_National_Football_Championship
http://www.cfrc.com/Archives/NC_Team_2008.htm

That year would be plastered all over the stadium. Alabama claims our 1936 title as theirs because some Geologist decided to call them his National Champs that year. They did the same thing in 1941, but people had heard of the Houlgate system, though nobody paid attention to it.
I kid you not.
 

That year would be plastered all over the stadium. Alabama claims our 1936 title as theirs because some Geologist decided to call them his National Champs that year. They did the same thing in 1941, but people had heard of the Holdgate system, though nobody paid attention to it.
I kid you not.

Correct, but I believe it was '34, not '36. And it's Houlgate.
 

Utah has three groups giving them National Championships: Anderson and Hester; Massey and Wolfe. I didn't see anything on Utah's page claiming to be the national champion.
 

at the games they have flags for 1934, 1936, and 1941...

Correct, but I believe it was '34, not '36. And it's Houlgate.

All of those are years that nobody but them consider Bama to be champs, but the 1936 is a monumental strech and the Geologist story is true...the linked site did not list this guys work since it was founded on work done with no explaination at how he arrived at his results. You are correct on my misspelling.
 

I just checked Alabama's website...

They only claim 12 NC instead of 14. 1936 is gone as is their claim to 1925.
 

(Hello Gophers! I post a similar message every year, but for some reason the Hole will no longer recognize the Monsignor. Thus, I've taken the alternative moniker of TheRightReverend. Nonetheless, I look forward to our biennial trip to the Twin Cities and really look forward to seeing the new stadium.)


I suggest below some of the more exciting, important or noteworthy games in this rivalry. At the end, I will tell you my favorite.


9. 1962: UW-14, UM-9. In a battle of titans (ranked #3 and #5), the Badgers win the Rose Bowl trip, helped by some controversial calls by the refs.

Your Holiness, Right Reverend Monsignor: Nice job on all this. I think you might enjoy a video replay of most of the 1962 Battle of Titans. The Brickhouse website, put up this past summer by the U of M Archives, has quite a few game films available on it. The 1962 season highlights film concludes with the season-ending game against Wisconsin. The tape ends just after the Gophers scored a go-ahead score with a couple minutes left. Ominously though, the last words we hear from narrator Ray Scott are: "But this game is not over." Apparently history has concluded that the atrocious roughing-the-passer call on Bobby Bell that kept the Badgers' game-winning drive alive wasn't a highlight. I don't think there is any conspiracy or coverup here. Old films got snipped and spliced for a variety of reasons. The 1940 season highlights film unfortunately no longer includes arguably the greatest run in Gopher history: Bruce Smith's 80-yarder against Michigan to secure the national championship that year.

That game might have been the highest that both teams were ranked when they faced each other. Nice of you to acknowledge the officiating crew's contributions to what was a really epic struggle. The highlights reel does show the Gophers having to settle for a field goal when most of the offensive line scrummed Bill Munsey into the end zone and was whistled for aiding and abetting.
 

The Monsignor's contribution here is probably the post of the year, in my opinion. I like trash talk with Badger fans as much as the next guy, but it's the history of this rivalry that does it for me. The fact the padre is a Badger fan makes it all the better since, while his interpretation is historically accurate, it's colored with just enough license to get my hackles up.

Thank you, Monsignor, for setting the stage for a great game this weekend!

GO GOPHERS!
 

Such a great thread for Gopher football history. Thanks to all the contributors.
 




Top Bottom