Reminiscent of Callahan at Nebraska

Joined
Sep 26, 2010
Messages
117
Reaction score
0
Points
16
As a Husker fan, I can’t help but compare this whole debacle to what occurred at Nebraska with Bill Callahan.

Both schools hired coaches with no prior head coaching experience at the collegiate level. And while Callahan did serve as a HC in the NFL, both coaches are most regarded for their competency not as head coaches but as assistances; Brewster as a TE coach and Callahan as an OL coach and offensive coordinator.

For Callahan, year 1 – a definite transition season – was a mess. Nebraska lost 30-3 to OU, gave up 70 points to Texas Tech, and for the first time in 42 seasons, they finished with a losing record at 5-6.

Years 2 and 3 were better, and I was feeling more optimistic. In 2005, they went 8-4 and beat Michigan in the Alamo Bowl, and in 2006, things started to come together (ok, I know this differs from Brewster 3rd year, but stick with me here). Nebraska swept the B12 North, finished the regular season 9-3, and came within 1 fumble of beating Texas at home.

Then it all fell apart. They finished the season with consecutive losses to OU in the Big 12 title game and to Auburn in the Cotton Bowl.

In year 4, the real misery set in. Nebraska was handled by USC, survived a missed FG to beat a MAC team at home, and won only 2 conference games, both of which came at the expense of B12 bottom feeders, Iowa St. and K-State.

The offense was serviceable, but the defense, which like Minnesota was coordinated by Kevin Cosgrove, was awful…the opposition scored 40+ points 6 times, including 76 scored by Kansas and 65 from Colorado.

I can write more on the Callahan era, but I’m already sick thinking about it, just as I’m sure you all don’t care to read about it.

So what does this all mean? Well, it's not good and it's probably going to get worse. Contrary to most, I think the offense is improving; for example, it's exciting to watch a player like Gray develop into a potential all Big-Ten type player. However, this team's downfall, like Nebraska in '07, is the defense, and if they're going to win any Big Ten games, they'll need to rely on their offense because the D can't stop anyone.

In the end, if everything plays out like it did in Lincoln, at this season's end, both Maturi and Brewster will get fired. And while clearing house won't solve everything, it will set this football program on a new track, and hopefully, eventually (because it will take time), things will get better.
 

A pair of star-cross'd morons coach their team;
Whose misadventur'd piteous overthrows
Doth with their termination of employment bury Golden Gopher fans' strife.
 

it is really amazing-a template does exist for hiring a coach and being successful at this level-why don't we follow that and avoid repeating the same mistakes made by others and ourselves over and over??? We need a guy who has many years of successful coaching at the collegiate level...period. COuld even be a I-AA coach. No NFL people, please. Dungy would be a great AD, not coach.
 

Thanks Husker. I didn't follow Nebraska that closely during the Callahan regime, but do recall that there was an uptick followed by a crash. A lot like here under Brewster.

And maybe the similarity will go further. Callahan did recruit most of the tremendous defense you fielded last season, including Suh. Maybe a different coach can get more out of our talent similar to what Pelini has done in Lincoln.
 

The offense was serviceable, but the defense, which like Minnesota was coordinated by Kevin Cosgrove, was awful…the opposition scored 40+ points 6 times, including 76 scored by Kansas and 65 from Colorado.

You should probably point out that the 2007 Nebraska D, just like the 2010 Minnesota D, has four new starters on the defensive line. I think THAT had more to do with Nebraska's defensive woes than Cosgrove.
 


You should probably point out that the 2007 Nebraska D, just like the 2010 Minnesota D, has four new starters on the defensive line. I think THAT had more to do with Nebraska's defensive woes than Cosgrove.


That was not the problem, the 2007 defense also had several guys on it who are now starting in the NFL and several more on rosters. Any way you look at it the talent and experience on that team was no where near that of what should be expected from the 112th ranked defense in the country. The poor coaching of Cosgrove had a ton to do with it and the fact that his players quit on him and may be starting to do it at Minnesota now as well. This was one of the main things that Osborne noticed and why he was let go, primarily due to the poor defense as their offenses performed very well under Callahan. Callahan to his credit and fault as well was loyal to Cosgrove and would not fire Cosgrove so he went down with him. In comparison, the 2008 defense which was a lot better than the 2007 version largely due to better coaching from Pelini had several key contributors and or starters who were walk-ons and included 5 new starters.
 

a template does exist for hiring a coach and being successful at this level...We need a guy who has many years of successful coaching at the collegiate level...period.

Yeah...just like Kirk Ferentz.

Or Bret Bielema.

Or Pete Carroll.

Or Pat Fitzgerald.

I could go on...
 




Top Bottom