Penn State Football - Will NOT refund seat contributions for 2020 if fans ask for a refund...

Donate To GopherHole
A_Slab_of_Bacon

A_Slab_of_Bacon

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 21, 2015
Messages
24,484
Reaction score
15,009
Points
113


Must be nice to have the luxury of a STH waitlist. You get to make these choices when there is a line of people waiting to buy tickets.

The angry fans don't have a leg to stand on here legally. They're forced donations. Not tickets.
If you're angry enough then cancel your tickets and let the next person in line take them.
 

mnsportsgeek said:
Must be nice to have the luxury of a STH waitlist. You get to make these choices when there is a line of people waiting to buy tickets.

The angry fans don't have a leg to stand on here legally. They're forced donations. Not tickets.
If you're angry enough then cancel your tickets and let the next person in line take them.
Click to expand...

Oh I duno if the idea of a required donation means you can keep it for sure.

You can call something anything you want on paper, courts might see it as something else. There's no magic word there.
 

mnsportsgeek said:
Must be nice to have the luxury of a STH waitlist. You get to make these choices when there is a line of people waiting to buy tickets.

The angry fans don't have a leg to stand on here legally. They're forced donations. Not tickets.
If you're angry enough then cancel your tickets and let the next person in line take them.
Click to expand...

I'm not a lawyer. However, two parties agreed to exchange money for a service. One party collected the money and refused to provide the service. They are wide open to a lawsuit. It doesn't matter how that payment is classified for tax purposes.

You can't keep money for a service that you didn't provide.
 


hello-world said:
I'm not a lawyer. However, two parties agreed to exchange money for a service. One party collected the money and refused to provide the service. They are wide open to a lawsuit. It doesn't matter how that payment is classified for tax purposes.

You can't keep money for a service that you didn't provide.
Click to expand...
No no no, you don't understand, that donation has noting to do with the tickets. It's just a nice donation with no bearing on a tangible product. Also student athletes are just normal students that happen to play sports and would be attending the school even if they weren't talented at sport.
/s
 

Ski U Master said:
No no no, you don't understand, that donation has noting to do with the tickets. It's just a nice donation with no bearing on a tangible product. Also student athletes are just normal students that happen to play sports and would be attending the school even if they weren't talented at sport.
/s
Click to expand...

You don’t need the /s for your first two sentences because you’re exactly right. You’re making a donation to the athletic department for the privilege of buying season tickets. You can bet Vikings season ticket holders aren’t getting a refund on their seat license, and those aren’t even tax deductible.

I’ve always thought these seat donations were a farse, but somehow they’ve stuck around.
 

hello-world said:
I'm not a lawyer. However, two parties agreed to exchange money for a service. One party collected the money and refused to provide the service. They are wide open to a lawsuit. It doesn't matter how that payment is classified for tax purposes.

You can't keep money for a service that you didn't provide.
Click to expand...

They took your donation to their department, and in turn allowed you to purchase season tickets. The donation is done deal. They’re refunding the season tickets.

Sleezy? Yes. Illegal? Probably not.
 

hello-world said:
I'm not a lawyer. However, two parties agreed to exchange money for a service. One party collected the money and refused to provide the service. They are wide open to a lawsuit. It doesn't matter how that payment is classified for tax purposes.

You can't keep money for a service that you didn't provide.
Click to expand...
My understanding is you can't claim a charitable contribution was made where the payment requires a service to be provided. Anyone that claims they didn't get a paid for service that has also claimed that amount as a donation on their taxes, is admitting to tax fraud.
 



mnsportsgeek said:
They took your donation to their department, and in turn allowed you to purchase season tickets. The donation is done deal. They’re refunding the season tickets.

Sleezy? Yes. Illegal? Probably not.
Click to expand...

Definitely illegal. You cannot offer to provide a service in exchange for a payment and then refuse to provide that service. No court in their right mind would come down on the other side of this.
 

hello-world said:
Definitely illegal. You cannot offer to provide a service in exchange for a payment and then refuse to provide that service. No court in their right mind would come down on the other side of this.
Click to expand...

They’re getting refunded for the service they paid for.
 

Donation is used to get by some illegal activities at times.
 

"They took your donation to their department, and in turn allowed you to purchase season tickets"

^ This is a transaction. If there are no tickets to buy, then they did not uphold their end of the transaction, and they must refund the money. It is not legal to keep that money. I could not do that with my side business, neither could anyone else, University or no.
 



Livingat45north said:
My understanding is you can't claim a charitable contribution was made where the payment requires a service to be provided. Anyone that claims they didn't get a paid for service that has also claimed that amount as a donation on their taxes, is admitting to tax fraud.
Click to expand...

Not relevant in a civil suit between ticket buyers and a University. But I agree with you that the system in use today is fraudulent.
 

Livingat45north said:
My understanding is you can't claim a charitable contribution was made where the payment requires a service to be provided. Anyone that claims they didn't get a paid for service that has also claimed that amount as a donation on their taxes, is admitting to tax fraud.
Click to expand...

You are correct that the donation made to receive the right to purchase season tickets are not deductible. But, our firm has the opinion that the 2020 donation will be deductible, since there are no season tickets attached. Staying on the ticket list is intangible.
 

I really don't care too much if it's technically legal (or not). Let the lawyers argue about that. It is flat-out wrong, and it is a slap in the face to some of PSUs loyal fan base. I would be really pissed. Losing some money PSU? Too bad... it is a consequence of the decision to shut things down due to COVID. Do the right thing and give the money back.
 

You must log in or register to reply here.



Top Bottom