Folks who want Mason back really don't remember that Texas Tech bowl game very well. Or all those instances when Mason's Gophers snatched defeat from the jaws of victory in the last 5 minutes of a game.
I agree the team has no offensive identity. I think it came into the year with one dependable WR & they've paid a price for it. I question the decision to scrap the spread; I've seen it run well and it is very capable of producing a dominant running game. Changing the system after two years means starting over - back to step #1 with assignments, reads, getting everyone on the same page, etc. I wonder why you recruit a kid who has the makings of a spread QB (Gray) and then change to an offensive system not as suited for his potential.
The greatest weakness of Mason's teams was that they were slow; the Gophers simply never had the horses at linebacker & defensive back to run with decent receivers - which is why, for example, they got torched by Texas Tech. That was not going to change, folks; Mason had plenty of years to recruit the necessary speed to the U and it didn't happen.
This isn't a defense of Brewster. As I've said, I don't understand scraping the spread & I don't believe the offense has been very well coached (for that matter, from what I saw last year, the spread wasn't being very well coached either).
With that said, there are two decisions here:
1) firing Mason;
2) hiring Brewster.
How the second turns out doesn't reflect on the 1st.