Mn Daily: Four Best Players of The Modern Era

Iceland12

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 12, 2008
Messages
24,758
Reaction score
2,421
Points
113
This article is in response to their "Mount Rushmore" article. Here's how they put it:

LLast week we picked the four faces of Minnesota Golden Gopher Football's Mt Rushmore, with former coach and player Bernie Bierman winning the fourth spot with 44% of the vote. His inclusion, along with Bronko Nagurski, Bruce Smith, and Bobby Bell, make it four men from the "Glory Years" which culminated with the school's last Big Ten title back in 1967. Since then, Minnesota hasn't won much, but there's still been some very good players, most of whom you're probably much more familiar with than the guys we talked about last week who player fifty, sixty, or seventy years ago or more.

So today is about giving the modern era guys their due by picking the four best to wear Maroon and Gold since 1967. Since we're again limited by our polling options, we're not going to open the voting to all four spots- and really, we don't need to. There are two automatics that should be on everybody's list, so we're putting them on to start. But we'll give you the opportunity to choose the other two names, and to do it we'll steal an idea from the fine folks at The Daily Norseman- comment voting! We have nine candidates (NINE!), so we'll put each name in the comments section, and you vote for your favorite two by rec'ing said player name comment. It would be helpful if you'd just choose two, but hey, free country and all. The nine candidates coming up but first, the two guys who don't even need to put to a vote:


Eslinger and Carter are in and they list Barber, Decker, Hamilton, Maroney, Karon Riley, Setterstrom, Spaeth, Thompson and Weber

http://www.thedailygopher.com/2013/...football-the-4-best-players-of-the-modern-era
 

It's from "The Daily Gopher" not MN Daily. Mods can you fix that. :banghead::banghead::banghead:
 

Foggie eslingee carter decker
 

They should have done a Bad Boyz Mt. Rushmore. Way more fun.
 

Four best of the modern era:

Tyrone Carter
Greg Eslinger
Darrell Thompson
Ben Hamilton

Other's receiving votes: MB3, Maroney, Decker, Ron Johnson, Dan Nystrom, Matt Spaeth, Mark Setterstrom, Karon Riley, Chip Lohmiller

Go Gophers!!
 


This is a tough list. . .

I think Carter and Eslinger are obvious, but the other ones are all difficult.

It's hard to put MB3 without Maroney (and vice versa).
Decker was sensational, but he was injured so often that it's hard to put him on the list for me.

I guess I would go. . .
Carter
Eslinger
MB3
Maroney
 

Four best of the modern era:

Tyrone Carter
Greg Eslinger
Darrell Thompson
Ben Hamilton

Other's receiving votes: MB3, Maroney, Decker, Ron Johnson, Dan Nystrom, Matt Spaeth, Mark Setterstrom, Karon Riley, Chip Lohmiller

Go Gophers!!

Lamanzer Williams, the "Dancing Bear" should have gotten some votes too. Doesn't he still hold the single season records for sacks and tackles for loss? Least he does in my 2010 Media Guide. Didn't he lead the nation in sacks that year, 1997? Might have to sign-up to SB Nation just to vote.
 

No Utect? probably botched the spelling and I wouldn't put him on, but I would have him on the list. I'd go Thompson and Spaeth. Although if Maroney had stayed four years I'd put him over Spaeth
 

I would add Thompson to Carter and Eslinger as first ballot selections. After that it's not so clear. I'd probably take MBIII.
 



Four best of the modern era:

Tyrone Carter
Greg Eslinger
Darrell Thompson
Ben Hamilton

Other's receiving votes: MB3, Maroney, Decker, Ron Johnson, Dan Nystrom, Matt Spaeth, Mark Setterstrom, Karon Riley, Chip Lohmiller

Go Gophers!!

This list is dead-on.
 

Four best of the modern era:

Tyrone Carter
Greg Eslinger
Darrell Thompson
Ben Hamilton

Other's receiving votes: MB3, Maroney, Decker, Ron Johnson, Dan Nystrom, Matt Spaeth, Mark Setterstrom, Karon Riley, Chip Lohmiller

Go Gophers!!

I might add Lamanzer Williams to that list?
 

Eslinger
Carter
MBlll
Decker

Maroney was sensational as a freshman, better as a sophomore and what ailed him as a Pro started to show it's ugly head as a junior to a pretty good degree. My favorite Gopher of all time if I had voted after his sophomore year. MBlll brought everything he had every game, every series and every game. Not as talented as Maroney, but an overall better player. Thompson also peaked early and wasn't able to sustain his high level of play 'til the end; which also showed when he was a pro. Decker was a stud; injuries be damned. The catch he made in the end zone againts Cal for a TD was the best I've ever seen college or pro; knocked cold and still caught the ball for the TD. Eslinger came out of the chute playing with balls and talent and kept getting better game after game for four years. Tyrone also came onto the scene as a freshman playing great and continued to improve right down to the end of his Gopher's career.
 

Ron Johnson

Tyrone Carter

Marion Barber

Eric Decker
 




Eslinger
Carter
Spaeth
Thompson

I agree. You have to go with the guys that won national awards.

Eslinger-Outland and Rimington
Carter-Thorpe Award
Spaeth-Mackey Award
Thompson- no awards but only gopher in history over 4,000 yards.
 

I don't think it's close for the first three. Eslinger, Carter, and Thompson. The last choice is a bit more difficult. I'll take Spaeth just for his toughness, and blocks that still hurt today. If you see former Wolverine Lamar Woodley, he's still getting out cobwebs from Spaeth's crushing block.
Lamanzer Williams had a great senior year, but prior to that he was not that great during the Wacker era. Decker was hurt far too often for consideration.
Barber and Maroney are close, and Setterstrom was rock solid, but played guard which often goes ununfairly noticed.
 




Anybody that leaves Thompson off this list just ain't paying attention.

A guy I know played for Michigan at the time Thompson played. Before the 1987 game at "The Dump", Bo Schembechler played a highlight reel of Thompson's freshman season, and after watching (mostly in silence), Bo announced "Meet the 1989 Heisman Trophy winner".

The guy ran for over 4,500 yards.
The guy averaged 5 yards per carry for his career.

I don't want to disparage any other player that posters have listed, but this guy is #1 for the modern era.
 

Eslinger
Carter
Spaeth
Thompson

I agree. You have to go with the guys that won national awards.

Eslinger-Outland and Rimington
Carter-Thorpe Award
Spaeth-Mackey Award
Thompson- no awards but only gopher in history over 4,000 yards.

Anybody that leaves Thompson off this list just ain't paying attention.

A guy I know played for Michigan at the time Thompson played. Before the 1987 game at "The Dump", Bo Schembechler played a highlight reel of Thompson's freshman season, and after watching (mostly in silence), Bo announced "Meet the 1989 Heisman Trophy winner".

The guy ran for over 4,500 yards.
The guy averaged 5 yards per carry for his career.

I don't want to disparage any other player that posters have listed, but this guy is #1 for the modern era.

You got it.
 

Thompson

Tyrone Carter

Greg Eslinger

The 4th one is hard.

Kind of a toss up between Decker, Johnson, Foggie, Barber, Maroney, Setterstrom, Ben Hamilton, Lamanzer Williams, and Spaeth.

I like Johnson because he was incredibly solid throughout his college years, and caught a terrible throw by Travis Cole for a touchdown to help defeat Ohio State.

But I think Maroney or Barber would be more recognizable figures for the position.



Sent from my PLAYSTATION PHONE using tapatalk
 

Thompson was before my time, so could someone fill me in on why a few of you think he's automatic? I know he's the career rushing leader, but Maroney was on pace to break that easily had he stayed for his senior year, and that was splitting carries with MB3, Tapeh, Russell, etc.
 

Part of the reason is just what you said. He stayed four years, and that is something that is important when considering who should represent an era of the gophers. Plus, the teams that Maroney played on, had a better line, and who knows what would have happened if he didn't have other competent teammates to share the ball with. Maybe he would have broke the record, or maybe he would have broken down even faster than he did.

Maroney, Barber, or Thompson.

I like them all.

Bottom line: Thompson holds the record. Stayed 4 years.

Now I'll talk out of my ass for a minute and say; the way it looks, he did a lot of that himself. Didn't have a crazy scary blocking scheme to run behind. Didnt have an all American o-line. And didn't have the privilege to get to hand a ball off to another great running back, if he felt winded, or banged up a little.

Check out some of his highlights if you can.


P.s. Sorry for the bad spelling or grammar, typing on this phone sucks.


Sent from my PLAYSTATION PHONE using tapatalk
 




Top Bottom