It's really depressing how Maturi took such juggernaut football and basketball programs and drove them into the ditch.
It's really depressing that someone as learned as you like to claim to be resort to this type of BS. Maturi could have built the programs, but did not. In fact, he took the limited success in football we'd had and rather than build on it, take the next step, he did the opposite.
In Basketball, he did just enough not to get in the way of the Tubby Smith hiring. There's been some bad luck involved in what's happened since, some bone headed administration issues that were tied to Maturi, and some failure on Tubby's part to take the next step. This next season will be Joel's defining moment. That program was truly in a shambles when Badger Joel took over and he didn't do enough soon enough to pull out of the nose dive.
In football, the team was average with two notable above average seasons. We had an offensive philosophy that worked, and a defense that didn't. We had been to several minor bowls and were fan support and a significant improvement in defense from becoming truly relevant in the post season world of college football. We were returning to campus, had beaten every big ten team for the first time in decades, and were poised to take the next step.
He did not drive that program into the ditch. He dug a huge whole. Pushed the program in. Buried it under a ton of concrete. Then Dirt. Then more concrete. Then a Badger W. He didn't derail a juggernaut, but he did everything in his power to make sure the next step wasn't taken.
In summary, at best to your comments, Joel may not have created the problems the programs had, but he certainly did next to nothing to solve those problems and more often than not, exacerbated the problems. He gets no flier on this. I too wish the programs would have won more, then again, I've been wishing Joel Maturi was demoted to be the very good assistant AD in charge of women's athletics as he should have been years ago. If that had happened, good chance the programs would have won more.