This is an interesting problem. The Big Ten and Pac Ten are the only two conferences that have to play 18 conference games. I think it may hurt them if they essentially swap out two BCS non-conference games in thier place. While the RPI will see them as equal, the selection committee may dock us for playing a weaker non-conference schedule. Even though while say Florida was off playing NC State and FSU, we were playing our 'extra' games against Ohio State and Michigan and in reality we have had it tougher. Florida will get credit for its tougher NC schedule.
When we had approximately 14 NC games, I felt that a mix of 5 BCS games, 4 mid-major/high low major and 5 cream puffs was acceptable, or 35%/30%/35%. Given the addition of 2 conference games, it would seem fair to remove one BCS game and one mid-major, leaving the mix 4/3/5 or33%/25%/42%. We have not come close to this the last 2 years, though you could argue that games like Cornell and NDSU were as good as mid-majors. We are almost assured two BCS games in Anaheim and another at Miami. We are also likely to have a mid-major quality game in Anaheim and have another with St. Joe's. So it would be nice to see them add one more BCS game and one more mid-major, preferably at home.
For reference here is the split of BCS/Mid-major/cream puffs for the last 5 years:
04-05: 31/8/61 13 games (BCS: Alabama, Oklahoma, FSU, Nebraska, Mid-major: Central Michigan)
05-06: 27/9/64 11 games (BCS: Maryland, Arizona State, UNLV (counting them as BCS), Mid-major UAB.)
06-07: 29/21/50 14 games (BCS: Iowa State, Clemson, Arizona State, UNLV, Mid Major: Southern Illiniois, UAB, Central Florida) Note: We played our way out of at least one more BCS game by losing every game of the Old Spice Classic, which would have made this by far the strongest schedule in recent years.
07-08: 25/17/58: (BCS: Iowa State, FSU, UNLV, Mid Major Cent. Michigan, Colorado State)
08/09: 17/17/66 (BCS: UVA, Louisville, Mid Major: Bowling Green, Colorado State)
One thing I can take away from this is that in addition to adding at least one BCS game per year, we could do a better job of replacing some of the cream puffs with decent mid-majors. Drake, Creighton, UW-Milwaukee, UW-Green Bay, Northern Iowa, all of these are within reasonable distance. I know they already play other BCS teams in thier home state but you'd think at least a couple of them would be available each year. It would help if NDSU and SDSU reached true mid-major status, but SDSU is far from that and NDSU may have touched it last year, but will now likely fall back.