Context
Good statistics but there should be some context for the numbers.
I was only 5 or 6 in Thompson's freshman year but I believe he came in and started from day one which helps his statistics.
When Maroney came in as a freshman in 2003 we had MBIII, Tapeh, and Terry Jackson II (rushed for 1000 yards in 2002). Maroney took over the #2 job and had an amazing freshman campaign. Considering he shared carries his production is astounding but he had an amazing line in front of him (the Gophers ranked #2 in rushing/game that season, #1 amongst BCS schools). Maroney managed 1121 yards on 162 carries, a 6.9 yard average.
MBIII won the #2 spot at RB as a freshman in 2001 with Tellis Redmon clearly the #1 back. Barber managed to accumulate 742 yards on only 118 carries, a 6.3 yard average. His line was definitely superior to the 2008 Gopher line.
DeLeon Eskridge won #1 the running back job in week three after having the #1 RB go down injured and having the other returning RB unable to return to form after a knee injury. His 652 yards were accumulated with 170 carries, a 3.8 yard average. The offense he ran out of was less running back friendly than what MBIII or Maroney had and the line was so much weaker the comparison is completely unfair.
The important question to ask is how would production have been different if you put Eskridge in the 2001 or 2003 offense. I have a hard time believing that Eskridge would have beat out Terry Jackson II like Maroney was able to do. However, in that offense I'm sure Eskridge still would have been able to average 5 yards a carry. Maroney and Barber both hit a hole faster than Eskridge, and both are unusually quick. Maroney has a gear that Eskridge can't hit and Barber has the best balance I've ever seen in a RB. To say that Eskridge doesn't have something that both of them had isn't much of an insult considering one is a pro-bowler and the other was a first round draft pick. Eskridge probably came in more similar to Amir Pinnix but was asked to carry the load as a true freshman because we lacked depth at RB.