College football officials to explore use of centralized, neutral replay system for postseason games

MisterGopher

Active member
Joined
Nov 12, 2008
Messages
364
Reaction score
199
Points
43
https://www.cbssports.com/college-football/news/college-football-officials-to-explore-use-of-centralized-neutral-replay-system-for-postseason-games/

Use of centralized, neutral replay officials has emerged as a prominent talking point on the heels of a sometimes contentious College Football Playoff, sources confirmed to CBS Sports.

The issue is considered a key agenda item at the annual College Football Officiating (CFO) meeting that begins Monday in Dallas. FBS commissioners and their officiating supervisors will meet through Wednesday for what was described as a "debriefing" following the 2024 season.

Centralized replay would put two persons not affiliated with a conference in charge of reviewing plays for all CFP games. Bowl games and perhaps even nonconference matchups in Week Zero could be added to that list.

Currently, the collaborative replay official and replay supervisor overseeing crews from a particular conference monitor games at the DVSports headquarters in Pittsburgh. In the future, those persons would be neutral.

It will also be discussed whether hiring one neutral person to oversee the entire replay process throughout the playoff.

The concept has long been used by the NFL. However, FBS conferences typically stay in their own silos with on-field officials and the use of replay officials paid by the leagues.
 

https://www.cbssports.com/college-football/news/college-football-officials-to-explore-use-of-centralized-neutral-replay-system-for-postseason-games/

Use of centralized, neutral replay officials has emerged as a prominent talking point on the heels of a sometimes contentious College Football Playoff, sources confirmed to CBS Sports.

The issue is considered a key agenda item at the annual College Football Officiating (CFO) meeting that begins Monday in Dallas. FBS commissioners and their officiating supervisors will meet through Wednesday for what was described as a "debriefing" following the 2024 season.

Centralized replay would put two persons not affiliated with a conference in charge of reviewing plays for all CFP games. Bowl games and perhaps even nonconference matchups in Week Zero could be added to that list.

Currently, the collaborative replay official and replay supervisor overseeing crews from a particular conference monitor games at the DVSports headquarters in Pittsburgh. In the future, those persons would be neutral.

It will also be discussed whether hiring one neutral person to oversee the entire replay process throughout the playoff.

The concept has long been used by the NFL. However, FBS conferences typically stay in their own silos with on-field officials and the use of replay officials paid by the leagues.

The NFL officiating process is even worse than college to the point of looking corrupt. Please don't model them for anything!
 

The NFL officiating process is even worse than college to the point of looking corrupt. Please don't model them for anything!
College Football as a whole seems to have no better ideas than to BE the NFL.

Sadly I fear in the long run they will do so much (shedding teams and so on) they end up "competing" with the NFL and that's a no win situation.

There's no individual leadership but someone(s) need to recognize that "We're popular to some extent because we're NOT the NFL... let's stay that way."
 

The NFL officiating process is even worse than college to the point of looking corrupt. Please don't model them for anything!
Correct
Selective use of “expedited replay” on some plays but not others is awful


Honestly college and pro are now both awful. It should be purely a challenge based system. Because if there is review initiated by the booth it’s selected usage is naturally unfair if the booth misses something. Whereas a challenge based system is always consistently applied.

Consistency > perfection for fairness IMO
 

I would only do a command center for Postseason play.

It is getting out of control. They need to start ignoring the Monday morning twitter feed and TV shows that state there is a problem. Just keep it simple.

1. Have challenges.
2. Replay TD's and Turnovers.
3. Fix egregious mistakes that they can fix in less than 30 seconds, like facemasks, down by contact, and spots.
4. Booth reviews in last 2 minutes of each half.
5. If it doesn't have a competitive impact on the game, leave it alone. (Reviewing a first down in the 1st quarter to see if it's 2nd and inches or a first down isn't needed.) 4th and inches or a 1st down? Sure.

Leave the Referee in the Center of the field and all replays should be done in an expedited booth fashion.
 






Top Bottom