Athlon: Grading College Football's 21 New Coaching Hires for 2017 (2. PJ Fleck)

BleedGopher

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 11, 2008
Messages
62,374
Reaction score
19,169
Points
113
per Athlon:

2. P.J. Fleck, Minnesota
Previous Job: Western Michigan Head Coach
Career Record: 30-22 (2013-16 Western Michigan)

After a successful four-year stint at Western Michigan, Fleck is taking his “Row the Boat” mantra to the Big Ten. Under Fleck’s direction, the Broncos reached new heights in 2016. Western Michigan finished 13–1, No. 15 in the final Associated Press poll and earned the program’s first trip to a New Year’s Six Bowl (Cotton). The 2016 season was the culmination of a relatively swift rebuild in Kalamazoo. The Broncos went 1–11 in 2013 but finished with 8–5 records in each of the next two seasons. Fleck is regarded for his work on the recruiting trail, and the Broncos inked the MAC’s best class from 2014-16. In addition to his time at Western Michigan, Fleck worked as a graduate assistant at Ohio State (2006) under Jim Tressel, spent three years at his alma mater Northern Illinois (2007-09), worked under Greg Schiano at Rutgers (2010-11) and spent a year in the NFL with the Buccaneers (2012). The Big Ten’s West Division provides an easier path to compete than the East. Fleck should increase the school’s recruiting profile and has already proven that he can be the CEO of a program. The energetic 36-year-old coach is a great fit at Minnesota.

Final Grade: A

https://athlonsports.com/college-football/grading-college-footballs-head-coach-hires-2017

Go Gophers!!
 

I wanted to say that is pretty generous but looking through the list there aren't a lot of guys with good resumes at the same level they got hired to so ... ok.
 


This is NOT a knock on Fleck. I just think it's silly to rank the new coaches before they've played a game. Some coaches prove to be the right fit for a new situation - other coaches prove to be the wrong fit. The time to give out report cards is at the end of the school year - not before the start of classes.

It would be interesting to take this same list and re-rank them after the 2017 season. I suspect you would see a lot of movement.
 

Was this straight up grading, or a curve?
 





Top Bottom