Search results

  1. R

    invalid fair catch signal

    Sure thing. And you are / were an official also. Meanwhile, back in reality..............
  2. R

    invalid fair catch signal

    Focus on this. Iowa at Northwestern (Wrigley Field) vs. Rutgers vs. Illinois At Nebraska Wisconsin vs. Ohio State at Indiana vs. Northwestern vs. Nebraska at Minnesota Northwestern vs. Maryland vs. Iowa (Wrigley Field) at Wisconsin vs. Purdue at Illinois Minnesota vs. Michigan State vs...
  3. R

    invalid fair catch signal

    The correct call in this situation is no call. This really sets a precedent, however we will never see this again, so maybe it doesn't set a precedent. I'll check back in a year and see how many times this gets called. Then we will really know the answer, as if most objective poeple don't...
  4. R

    invalid fair catch signal

    What's the philosophy about a call that is rarely made and wasn't called on the field? You're jumping around. First you cite rules as factual. Then I ask you to cite where they are factual. Now you completely change direction and go to philosophy. Because what you cited as factual isn't in the...
  5. R

    invalid fair catch signal

    You're not answering my specific questions with specifics. I read your post, and I'm not aware of some of the rules you cite. Just take the loss.
  6. R

    invalid fair catch signal

    Permanently banned for what? asking question where no one can provide factual answers? Consequently really making my point for me. The best way to win an argument really, have others do it for you.
  7. R

    invalid fair catch signal

    Knows the rules better than the "official" on here. And that's not debatable after the "offcials" last post.
  8. R

    invalid fair catch signal

    What level of football did you officiate? Because I'd like that answer before I have some fun with your "facts". The reality is it's pretty obvious what the answer is. I'd like you to cite in the rules where your third sentence has any meaningful bearing. The second sentence in your second...
  9. R

    invalid fair catch signal

    So no one can explain why this happens all the time, but isn't called. And no one can offer an explanation for what happened in the Arizona State Washington game. And one poster is apparently an official. At some level of football. Ha ha.
  10. R

    invalid fair catch signal

    Arizona State - Washington.
  11. R

    invalid fair catch signal

    Was it called on the field? Why do we see this all the time, and why is it rarely ever called? Did I argue it was the incorrect call? Can you link where I indicated the call wasn't technically correct? You don't call this hardly ever, and you should never call this at a critical point in a game...
  12. R

    invalid fair catch signal

    And I returned punts at the D1 level. Maybe Maxy can answer and explain the discrepancy in the number of time we see this, versus the number of times it is called. I'll wait on that.
  13. R

    invalid fair catch signal

    Twice after yesterday's game. Not called either time. How often have you seen it called in the last decade? How often have you seen it. Of course it's subjective. Happy with the win, but to say this wasn't an incredibly lucky and controversial call is ignorant. The numbers and facts bear this...
  14. R

    invalid fair catch signal

    Correct call. Never gets called. In fact the same thing happened in another game yesterday. This is never called. Very subjective, and we are incredibly lucky.
  15. R

    I don’t agree with Fleck “We got closer, and you’ve got to get closer before you can get over it."

    On the recruiting trail, he's been rumored to do some pretty low class things. When I say "rumored", it's more than rumored.
  16. R

    I don’t agree with Fleck “We got closer, and you’ve got to get closer before you can get over it."

    When Kirk Ferentz and Jerry Kill both throw shade, there is fire in all that smoke.



Top Bottom