To me, it would depend on how many of the current players stick around. If a lot of them depart, then I want new HS commits to replace them. If they stick around, then I say take a grad transfer that can play a role around them.
I find it laughable that the author of this article wonders “The affection is real. Is it enough for Pitts to reconsider and Whalen to take her back?”
I think that ship has probably sailed...