What are your thoughts on pursuing Auston Matthews in the offseason?
I'd be all in on Matthews, though I don't think we have the assets to get him and I don't think Toronto is going to shop him cheaply now that they've won the #1 pick and still have him under contract for 2 years while still being in his prime.
If they took Gus, a 1st and 1-2 young guys, I'd do that trade in a heartbeat. I think it will cost significantly more than that unless Matthews tells them he doesn't want to be there.
The use of Wally in the trade I think is an interesting one. Can you sell high on him and land him for Matthews straight up? I would probably also do that trade given this team as constructed (with Matthews) I think is that close to a title given how it reshuffles you down the middle while adding not just a 1C, but a top 5 center in the league. I'm not as negative on Gus as some people have become dramatic about, given in 22-23 he posted at 2.5 GSAA in the playoffs and in 24-25 another 2.5 GSAA in the playoffs playing behind considerably weaker teams.
Maybe there is a way you can get creative with it, giving them some NHL caliber guys while offloading Gus's contract as well (such as Gus paired with Hartman/Ek) that let you stay nimble with the dollar amount. Is an added piece that we have 13.6mil in cap needing to sign quite a few guys to fill a roster so this would keep that intact while landing the 1C to get Hughes his extension (and also becoming more team USA lol).
All that being said, I think the cost for Matthews realistically is higher than the upper 2 I mentioned. I think if Toronto sucks again, he may become available at the deadline for someone like Gus and picks. I think as it sits right now, Toronto is not thinking this is a full on rebuild as they still have a lot of really high value assets (Nylander, Knies, Matthews, Reilly, #1 pick which is an NHL ready forward or defenseman)