Football - Yes
Men's Hoops - Nope (Johnson hire)
Women's Hoops - Nope (Whalen hire)
Men's Hockey - Nope
Women's Hockey - Nope
Wrestling - Nope
Volleyball - Nope
Softball - Nope
Baseball - Nope
On paper, that's a pretty depressing resume for an AD but I'll never claim to have enough insight to determine how much of the blame resides with the UM Administration's ineptitude and possible financial restraints placed on Coyle.
Wrestling no one going to do what JRob did at his best, Iowa is still a wagon and Penn State has the best high school wrestling in their backyard to recruit from. One can certainly argue they are better now than they were at the end when JRob resigned. Little surprised he kept that one in house TBH or more that eh was allowed to keep that one in house.
Hockey kinda the same as wrestling Lucia had a better overall run early on, reached the pinnacle of his sport twice, but I would certainly argue Motzko last four years were better than Lucia last four years. Seems like Woog, Lucia and Now Motzko went through the same cycle in the post Herbie era. I am willing to bet when we replace Motzko the powers that be in our local hockey community will once again tell whomever the AD is what to do.
Women's hockey Brad Frost was an assistant on the inaugural team, they have had two coaches. Perhaps if Sparty and Michigan started fielding women's teams it would cut off Wisconsin and Ohio States recruiting efforts there, or perhaps the gophs could be less provincial in that sport.
Baseball the new guy is what the third coach since the Korean war? Will see how years two and three go but 14 lead that program into the ground post 2018
Softball besides Piper, Coyle did hire Traschell who got us to the world series and then somehow the two seed in a regional when we were number two in the country the following year when they were even better.
Men's basketball seems pretty obvious what the parameters were and after we didn't get Gates we went a certain way. I'm willing to judge Coyle there based on how Niko does since he had the freedom to pick who he wanted.
Won't defend the Whalen hire but everyone loved it at the time so it seems pretty convenient to bitch about it now. Will see how Dawn does.
Volleyball, Hugh was better but last I check we are still a top 25 program in the country, not like they've bottomed out. Will see if they can get to a final four again with this coach
Soccer seems to be doing better.
DO people hate Coyle because he mumbled too much in a press conference in 2017? Everyone seems to be in a rush to run off the Best AD we've had since segregation ended. There's a reason Coyle's name gets mentioned when USC or other big time programs have openings, personally I thought he did a good job of being proactive and making Pitino, Whalen and Lucia's buyouts more stomachable. I for one don't want to go back to Maturi and Megatongue type AD's again
www.twincities.com
