All about Max Brosmer Making the Cut

Donate To GopherHole

A_Slab_of_Bacon said:
Will be interesting how long the "KOC is the quarterback whisperer" story line lasts.

Seen that label on many folks in the NFL and college and it ALWAYS wears off eventually ...
Click to expand...
Trestman comes to mind (though if you look at the stats of the QB's when he was either a QB coach or OC, many had career years).
 





Brosmer comes in as the 4th QB of the day. Howell looked better than reported. Rypien didn't look good. Brosmer looks good on the 4th drive. Frankly, JJ's throws weren't awesome to start the day.
 


swede2 said:
Brosmer comes in as the 4th QB of the day. Howell looked better than reported. Rypien didn't look good. Brosmer looks good on the 4th drive. Frankly, JJ's throws weren't awesome to start the day.
Click to expand...
JJ hardly threw passes in college and knew all the defense play calls and is coming off a knee injury. I am not sure he's the answer this year.
 





Word said:
JJ hardly threw passes in college and knew all the defense play calls and is coming off a knee injury. I am not sure he's the answer this year.
Click to expand...
He’s 100% healthy. He made big time throws at Michigan, you can’t win the national title without em. They blew teams out so he hardly threw in the second half of most games.
 

beatles said:
He’s 100% healthy. He made big time throws at Michigan, you can’t win the national title without em. They blew teams out so he hardly threw in the second half of most games.
Click to expand...
I hope he does well because I'm a Vikings fan but wasn't a fan of the draft pick. I'm still skeptical.
 





Word said:
JJ hardly threw passes in college and knew all the defense play calls and is coming off a knee injury. I am not sure he's the answer this year.
Click to expand...
KOC took a journeyman rocket scientist and in 4 hours coached him up and won an NFL game with him. More than one. I'm pretty sure I trust his opinion of a QB he is partly risking his coach of the year status on in JJ. And the peripherals of JJ at Michigan throwing were outstanding, not sure what you're talking about. Completed 72% passes. He was hands down the best quarterback in all of college football on third and fourth down. Easily. Yards per attempt, 3rd and 4th down conversion, QB rating and on and on. Nevermind his mental makeup, leadership skills and accountability, all off the charts. I would argue whoever makes the Michigan hardly throws argument has literally never watched him play a snap, and is parroting someone else's shit take. My two cents.
 

Harrymannback77 said:
KOC took a journeyman rocket scientist and in 4 hours coached him up and won an NFL game with him. More than one. I'm pretty sure I trust his opinion of a QB he is partly risking his coach of the year status on in JJ. And the peripherals of JJ at Michigan throwing were outstanding, not sure what you're talking about. Completed 72% passes. He was hands down the best quarterback in all of college football on third and fourth down. Easily. Yards per attempt, 3rd and 4th down conversion, QB rating and on and on. Nevermind his mental makeup, leadership skills and accountability, all off the charts. I would argue whoever makes the Michigan hardly throws argument has literally never watched him play a snap, and is parroting someone else's shit take. My two cents.
Click to expand...
OK PA. Dobbs played better with less time to prepare. He actually got worse the longer he was with the Vikings. Darnolds season last year was amazing though. Just saying I probably wouldn't use Dobbs as my measuring stick of KOC's greatness. That would definitely be a shit take. Darnold would have been a much better example.

Do you think Max Brosmer's (or any other QB's) completion percentage would have been higher if he knew which play the other team was running?

BTW I really like KOC. My pumping up Max is mostly tongue in cheek but maybe you're not picking up on that. Still skeptical McCarthy is the long term answer. Would be glad to be wrong though.
 
Last edited:


Word said:
OK PA. Dobbs played better with less time to prepare. He actually got worse the longer he was with the Vikings. Darnolds season last year was amazing though. Just saying I probably wouldn't use Dobbs as my measuring stick of KOC's greatness. That would definitely be a shit take. Darnold would have been a much better example.

Do you think Max Brosmer's (or any other QB's) completion percentage would have been higher if he knew which play the other team was running?

BTW I really like KOC. My pumping up Max is mostly tongue in cheek but maybe you're not picking up on that. Still skeptical McCarthy is the long term answer. Would be glad to be wrong though.
Click to expand...
Would you take Dobbs or Brosmer?
 




I’ll eat my shoe if JJ turns into a top 10-15 NFL QB….someday. The guy had every advantage imaginable in college including (allegedly) knowing the defensive calls. Are Vikes fans taking crazy pills? He’s a reach.

Pulling for Brosmer. Phsucally hes not all that but loved his release, quick decisions, maturity.
 



Word said:
OK PA. Dobbs played better with less time to prepare. He actually got worse the longer he was with the Vikings. Darnolds season last year was amazing though. Just saying I probably wouldn't use Dobbs as my measuring stick of KOC's greatness. That would definitely be a shit take. Darnold would have been a much better example.

Do you think Max Brosmer's (or any other QB's) completion percentage would have been higher if he knew which play the other team was running?

BTW I really like KOC. My pumping up Max is mostly tongue in cheek but maybe you're not picking up on that. Still skeptical McCarthy is the long term answer. Would be glad to be wrong though.
Click to expand...



OK PA. Dobbs played better with less time to prepare. He actually got worse the longer he was with the Vikings.
Word said:
OK PA. Dobbs played better with less time to prepare. He actually got worse the longer he was with the Vikings. Darnolds season last year was amazing though. Just saying I probably wouldn't use Dobbs as my measuring stick of KOC's greatness. That would definitely be a shit take. Darnold would have been a much better example.

Do you think Max Brosmer's (or any other QB's) completion percentage would have been higher if he knew which play the other team was running?

BTW I really like KOC. My pumping up Max is mostly tongue in cheek but maybe you're not picking up on that. Still skeptical McCarthy is the long term answer. Would be glad to be wrong though.
Click to expand...
Great point in that first paragraph.

The more KOC screwed with Josh Dobbs, the worse he played. When KOC just let Dobbs ad lib they had good results.

Sometimes these egomaniac coaches get too full of themselves to just roll with what works.

I'd rather be like Mike Ditka than Kurt Rambis, just be happy you won, even if Buddy Ryan or some #2 made it happen, and you got most of the credit from the average schmuck.
 

I am always down for a bet @GopherWeatherGuy. If both things happen: JJ finishes the season and the Vikings make the playoffs - I will leave for 6 months and vice versa. Are we on? Let’s make it interesting. I am hearing this is supposed to be a pretty good squad this year. Seems like high expectations for the boys in purple in 2025-26. They just need a QB.
 

Pompous Elitist said:
I am always down for a bet @GopherWeatherGuy. If both things happen: JJ finishes the season and the Vikings make the playoffs - I will leave for 6 months and vice versa. Are we on? Let’s make it interesting. I am hearing this is supposed to be a pretty good squad this year. Seems like high expectations for the boys in purple in 2025-26. They just need a QB.
Click to expand...

The Vikings will be good this year and JJ will be just fine. Brosmer will be the 3rd string QB. That is all.
 


You must log in or register to reply here.



Top Bottom